UK time is: 12:22:44
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

"Rules Is Rules"... Or Is They?



However, while it's true that EPL football is above all a business, the Premier League's refusal to make a final decision today as to whether his transfer is either valid or void is completely bush league. Without claiming to understand the porous details of what legally makes a transfer valid or invalid, it seems to me that the whole point of having a deadline for transfers is that it be respected. If documents A, B, & C need be signed sealed and delivered before midnight in order for a transfer to be valid, then anything less than A, B, & C, should logically mean that the transfer is voided.

Why should it take "until some time next week" for everyone to know where they stand? The only possible reason is that Premier League officials plan to use a criteria for examining the deal that is extraordinary and that exposes the entire process to scrutiny and scepticism.

What hangs in the balance until then are potentially crucial points which could be gained/lost by either Pompey or Man City in their drives for European spots. More importantly, a Zimbabwean football player who has sincerely given his all to his team and their fans since arriving in England is left in a humiliating purgatory.

If the EPL says no to the transfer next week, he will have to come back to a club and manager who have made it clear that he is considered expendable. If the deal goes ahead, then he will question as to whether the club he is to play for really wanted him after all.

Would the Premier League head office have humiliated a high profile English player, say an Ashley Cole or Frank Lampard in such a cruel and demeaning manner by leaving him so hanging? I sincerely doubt it.

There are many who need to apologize to Benjani for this incident, for the good of the English game, yet I doubt any of the suits will be gracious enough to do so, so I'll apologize to him on behalf of all of the Fratton faithful who admire and respect him as one of us. Thanks a bunch Benji and you'll always get a cheer from us, whomever you play for.

Written by Toronto4Pomey.

The views within this article are the views of the individual who wrote and submitted this piece, sometimes solely theirs. They are not necessarily shared by the Vital Pompey Site Journalists.

Join the Vital Pompey Debate
The Journalist

Writer: pompeyrug Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Saturday February 2 2008

Time: 10:21AM

Your Comments

this is a crackin' read Toronto4Pomey - thanks for putting it forward...
pompeyrug
The reason why it's not so clear is because Portsmouth are arguing that City tried to unlawfully sabotage the deal as they got cold feet. Therefore it wouldn't be fair to void the deal for us.
stillthewhizz
this whole situation is a farce now, surely it must be simple a deal didnt go through, man city said it didnt go through - it appears now that we are 'desperate' for this to go through - so i think we are probably pushing for this more than citeh... benji's heart isnt in the move, i think that he didnt want this and as others have said - with ChrisW writing something in the forum today - i think citeh picked up on this... we seem prepared to screw players other, yep its a 'business' now but im detesting the 'cut throat' world it has become... should the premier league sanction a ruling that now allows him to go, then they are basically 'making up the rules as they go along' there is not point having a 'deadline' if it isnt kept, it makes a mockery of th system that was 'meant' to be for the good of the game... 'if' the deal falls through, i fear for benji as it'll be hard for him to look at 'arry with the trust that he did, this could also backfire on others, as who would have thought this time a few days ago we would have even concidered selling benji?
pompeyrug
but at the same time if benji doesnt want to go how is it fair on him to make him - citeh clearly picked up on the fact he 'didnt' want to go?
pompeyrug
Terrific article, Toronto4Pomey, and I agree with all you've said. For personal and football reasons, I hope he stays with us which will enable us to show how we feel about him and his continued employment at Fratton Park. Deals have been 'scuppered' in the past due to the midnight deadline I wonder why the Premier league is risking creating a precedent over this transfer. It was said that Manchester Citeh had got cold feet, so is this Pompey pushing and Man C resisting or both after the same same result, I wonder.
Et_tu_Pompeii
i would like to hope that we are both pushing for the same result... what i think that result is is one that sees benji stay here - both sides want this, but i think if truth be known the feeling i am getting is that we are pushing for it to go through citeh are pushing for it not...
pompeyrug
Long live Benjani. I was aghast at the news that he was off to City. If there's one man who's given his all for the club it's Benji. It just goes to show that EPL is no more than a buisness trade off today, money rules. I fear for the cohesiveness of the team after this debacle and truly hope that Benji will stay and score another twelve goals for us. Right behind you Benji, let's get back to what a team and club should really be about. Nieve i know but forever in hope. Play up Pompey..
cornypomp
thats what most of us have built our pompey following lives on itsnt it cornypomp 'hope', so we cannot lose this whatever can we i guess... welcome to vital pompey too mate, good to have you here.
pompeyrug
The hard facts are, that our most popular player and top goal scorer, who a few days ago was stating his future loyalty to our great club, was forced against his will to join Manchter City. The man responsible for this disgusting state of affairs is one HARRY REDKNAPP. Who with this one action has destroyed all team spiret and the total well-being of Pompey Football Club.
007
Sorry about the spelling mistakes, not as cool as usual, whats Steve Coppels telephone no.
007
Don't be niave 007. Given a bit of time Defoe will prove to be a brilliant but. Take sentiment out of argument. Benji has 2 & a bit years to go, at 29 he at his peak. in business terms 8-9m for Benji is a fantastic bit of business for the club. So he is our top goal scorer but we can live without it. HR was told buy 1 sell 1. There is no destroying of team spirit or moral, these are hardened footballers, very use to the coming & goings of team mates.
storagematt
Matt, not in my world, or it appears in the eyes of many others. Integrety and honesty are still uppermost.
007
Nice stuff T4P. Of course rules are rules and no wonder Paul Jewell is upset.
eastneydave
Thnks guys. Whizz, I didn't read the bit about citeh trying to sabotage the deal until after I wrote the above. I just feel the EPL has handled the whole thing without an ounce of class and made an ugly situation grotesque. There are good arguments either way to have not let him go in the first place, but to humiliate him by not dealing with the matter right away is atrocious.
Toronto4Pompey
For the Premier league to sanction the deal now eould surely destroy any credibility that they have. If as seems MCFC reneged on an agreement to buy him he should return to Pompey and city should pay compensation to Pompey.
Steve C
haha i like it steve c
jbaker
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. storagematt 95
2. PFCblue 76
3. mslorna48 64
4. pompeyrug 55
5. Emsworthianblue 39
6. Pompeytim 31
7. Lemmi 26
8. eastneydave 25
9. PompeyJake 12
10. Jimsmithswig 11

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
13. Newport 42 13 14 15 -3 53
14. Wimbledon 42 13 13 16 -5 52
15. Cheltenham 42 12 16 14 -8 52
16. Portsmouth 42 12 15 15 -12 51
17. Accrington 42 12 14 16 -3 50
18. Hartlepool 42 13 10 19 -2 49
19. Morecambe 42 12 13 17 -14 49

Breaking League News

Iron unlikely to make changes
Scunthorpe : 18/04/2014 11:07:00
Team News v Burton
Hartlepool : 18/04/2014 11:05:00
Team News v Newport
Wimbledon : 18/04/2014 11:03:00
Team News v Wycombe
Northampton : 18/04/2014 11:02:00
Team News v Scunthorpe
Morecambe : 18/04/2014 11:00:00
Team News v Hartlepool
Burton : 18/04/2014 10:58:00
Cod Army Preview: Cheltenham v Fleetwood
Fleetwood : 18/04/2014 09:00:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Pompey v Bristol Rovers?
Suggested By:  
Pompey win 67%
Bristol Rovers win 0%
Draw 33%