Vital Football

Sven: was he good or bad?

Sven: was he good or bad?
Unfortunately, as always, a question isn't as simple as it first appears, and can really be broken down into a few "sub" questions:

How good was Sven?
Were the players in the England side good?
What is a good performance for the England side?
How much was down to Sven?

The first part is quite easy: Under Sven, England qualified for 3 major championships, with, up until the game against Northern Ireland, an unbeaten record - and only ever losing 5 competitive games, 3 of which in quarter finals, 1 to the eventual world cup winners, and 2 on penalties, and it must also be mentioned that no other European country achieved 3 consecutive quarter finals, and only Brazil did worldwide - Not bad! And to cap it all, England went from ranked 17th in the world, when he took the job, to 4th in the world, before the shock defeat to Portugal in the world cup (slipping 1 place to fifth). He is officially rated as England`s second most successful manager after Sir Alf Ramsay. Overall, he was very successful. And to add to this, we now have what scientists would call a "control". Since he became Man City manager, we can see how good at managing he is compared to some of "the greats" - and an early victory against Manchester United, and them sitting in a champions league spot, proves he can cut it with the best, so it seems there is little to fault about Sven.

The second question is not much harder: The likes of Frank Lampard, John Terry, David Beckham, Michael Owen, Sol Campbell, Wayne Rooney, and so on are all good players. I could go on for pages listing all the good players Sven had to choose from, so I think that yes, the England squad was good.

Unfortunately, you then have to pick the right players - playing Frank Lampard and Steven Gerrard is like playing a centre back at full back, and no-one in there right mind would do that would they Steve? Quite simply, the 2 play in identical positions, but other than that, I can find little to fault his team selections. In fact, much has been said about his negative substitutions, but with only 5 defeats in his career as England manger, they can hardly be faulted. But, picking the right players is even more complex than just picking the players in the right positions. The Ashley Cole/Joe Cole combination worked well, and the recent example of the Heskey/Owen combination proved how much a difference it can make. And back to the Frank Lampard/Steven Gerard problem, they just didn't play together. But once again, we must look at the results, and say that his methods did actually work.

The last two questions however are much harder to answer, as they are a matter of opinion. In fact, before the Sven era, it was not something I personally had much of an opinion about, my earliest memories of supporting England were the France '98 world cup - but that is for another time. Going into the next world cup, I still did not follow much football, as I spent all my time playing it, and going into Euro '04, I still didn`t have much of an idea who Wayne Rooney was. But when we got to 2006, I had had enough time to look at our squad, look at the players, see how good they were, and look at other teams players, and asses how good they were. I checked to see who people thought could win, and as far as I could see, it would be a 3 hoarse race, between England, Brazil, and Argentina. My money went strait on Brazil to win. People mentioned Italy, but one look at there side, and I said "no way" - I still do.

Argentina and Germany immediately appeared to be the two best teams playing, and with poor performances from England, Brazil, and Italy, I naively decided England and Brazil would both pick up there form later in the tournament. Neither did, but that didn't change the fact that in that world cup, I had expected England to reach the quarter finals, and they failed miserably - although so did Brazil, and in fact, so did Argentina and Germany. But that is one defeat, in 1 major championship, that I can say "we should have won" - I didn't expect the final, so it was a near miss, I'm sure the others were the same. Overall, from what I now know and understand, a semi-final is a good performance, a quarter final is average, and anything less is a disaster. On that basis, which I will leave open to debate, England under Sven did averagely in 1 major championship. Not a disaster really, and compared to the man that took his job, absolutely marvellous.

And the final question "how much was down to Sven?" is interesting to say the least.

He picked the players, he was blamed when England lost - although in my opinion unfairly - and the players got credit when England won. He was accused of making negative substitutions, but they worked, generally. He picked the teams and he set out the tactics. Once again, returning to our "control", we have another manager, with the same set of players, some better than Sven ever had, and we are on the verge of failing to qualify for Europe, needing a victory against a strong Croatia side, thanks to a last gasp winner for Israel.

In summary, as a manger, Sven converted a team ranked 17th to 4th, he only lost 5 games, he was the second most successful England manager ever, he achieved a feat bettered only by Brazil, he lost his chance for glory by penalties, twice, and following his reign, Steve McClaren has failed to achieve the same standards with a better group of players.

In answer to the question "was Sven Goran Eriksson getting the most from a poor England side, or was he underachieving?" I must answer, that he was getting exactly what England should have expected. Not better, not worse. With the players, we could have done better, but equally, as our current manager is proving, we could have done much, much worse.

Written by pompeycarpet.

The views within this article are the views of the individual who wrote and submitted this piece, sometimes solely theirs. They are not necessarily shared by the Vital Pompey Site Journalists.

To join the Vital Pompey debate - in the forum or with comments on articles - simply take a few seconds to register an account.

Date:Sunday November 18 2007
Time: 12:13AM

Best of International Football News



here you go carpet - i was able to transfer it from the forum into here for you as you orignally wanted... this takes some reading, but i found it worth it. my own thoughts are eriksson failed with england tbh - yep his record on paper looks okay but we didnt always have to play 'the hardest' sides did we? tactically he was poor, he didnt seem to have a clue and you could see he didnt know either more often than no... all too often he would revert to a negative mould and we would sit back and sit back until we eventually cracked then we lost, brazil and portugal just 2 such occasions. we had a couple of real chances to have won tournaments under him but they were blown... given the choice of him or spineless tho, altho i wouldnt want either really going back to sven would be the lesser of 2 evils...
18/11/2007 00:18:00
Great article Carpet.. well thought out and well constructed. I won't answer each of the points separately in any great detail as I will hog the responses, but I I will say is that when Sven as appointed there was nobody worth giving the job to. He got slated from day one purely and simply because he was not English. His lack of Englishness immediately became a stick that everybody (supporters as well as the press) could beat him with and boy did he get beaten. His performances in major competitions was always dissapointing mainly becuase of the players he had at his disposal - But players I will add that have large egos and have lost the pride and the feeling of what it means to play for England - It's funny how since Sven that the players have all of a sudden become blameless. Sure I think Sven made some odd decisions and wound me up at times when he did not show any passion and I also think that he lacked the killer touch and didn't know how to instruct his team to kill off a game .. but in Summary... How good was Sven? - Well better than most actually. Were the players in the England side good? - Yes, and too big for their boots. we had the best England team I'd ever seen (on paper) going into Euro 04 & WC 06 What is a good performance for the England side? - With the current set-up Semi finals should be expected How much was down to Sven? - A fair amount but a lot of the blame have to go the the players the press and I'm affraid to say it us as supporters - We do not have a devine right to win major competitions .... But (as a cheap parting shot) we shoudl Mr McClaren have a devine right to qualify for them -
18/11/2007 07:45:00
thanks rug for putting the article on here - i had not originally meant it to b so long, but got a little carried away. From the previosu two competitions, we possibly should have beaten portugal, and in euro 2004, we did - its just sols goal was disallowed - and im sure that had we won that, we would nhave gone on to win the tournament. I think that sven had to put up with a lot of stick as england manager, but his record speaks for itselfhe was succsesful
18/11/2007 10:43:00
Not bad carpet I enjoyed your argument. Sven would have been a hero of the Alf Ramsay kind had he lifted the trophy....remember the guy in charge of the England 2003 World Cup Rugby side that later went to Southampton as Director of Football... now what was his name (does it really matter)...If a jockey rides the winner of the Derby everybody wants to shake his hand, but there again if he falls off the horse in the home straight ??
18/11/2007 11:26:00
Our problem is that we convince ourselves that we have world class players, and we do not, and that we ahve the best men in authority to win us matches and we do not. We have some decent players but they are not the best in the world by any means, and we keep picking players who are not up to the job, and we are afraid to give youth a chance.
18/11/2007 11:43:00
sadly sven didnt learn from his mistakes as far as his selection for england was concerned - always selectiong 'the star names' and not neccessarily the 'right people', not giving enough youth a chance has been our downfall for years, spineless steve has been given a 2nd chance, it is now for him to take it and make changes even if it 'offends' the egos of too many of out footballers that need this happening to them - he will earn much more respect if he does this...
18/11/2007 12:03:00
mcclaren dropped david beckham - and when he recalled him, beckham started playing better than he ever had before, as he knew his place was not safe. frank lampard, having been dropped, could come back better - but not if you play him alongside steven gerrard - and i am sure that other playors will pick up there game if they realise there place is not safe anymore. but it needs a bit of guts to pick a team like that.
18/11/2007 12:15:00
Do we need England in EURO - Yes. Do we want to fail yet again - No. Is qualifying for the World Cup more important - Yes. Will we win EURO if we get there - NO. And finally Do I love Pompey more than England...definitely YES !!
18/11/2007 12:26:00
oh, how would love to see one of the two win a major championship...
18/11/2007 13:11:00
Sven did a decent job whilst with England. With the squad of players we had though we should have done better and he seemed unable to get England to do the basics (like passing the ball) when we came close to success.
18/11/2007 13:56:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Worthy of a new deal?

So, Danny Rose, as we know, isn't going to play again this season. As things stand this would mean he'll not pull on a Pompey shirt again as his contract expires in the summer.

Sickening Rotherham winner

Losing on Saturday was bad enough, the fact this was an added time winner more so. The cherry on the cake was the fact Rotherham's goal came from ex-Pompey full back Joe Mattock.

On this day in history...22nd January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd January.

On this day in history...21st January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st January.

Portsmouth Archived Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Should Danny Rose get a new deal?
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Yes, get it done ASAP80%
Yes, once he's proven his fitness10%
No, regardless of his injury10%
I'll sit on the fence - KJ knows best0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

Vital Football Comment