Vital Football

Challenge Dave - Episode 1 Part 1

Challenge Dave - Episode 1 Part 1
Here's one for him… should he choose to accept - The history of Pompey's record signings i.e. who was the first and who was then the next player to sign who was more expensive and so on.

Will not mention the sender but thanks very much. So it is on with the lycra cat suit and off on the beach buggy.

Firstly it seems as though this has never been undertaken before. So it was out with books and the brain and dig and I trust all I uncovered is correct.

Portsmouth FC as we all know was formed as a professional club on 5 April 1898 the first such club on Portsea Island. There had been an amateur club called Portsmouth AFC in the town since 1884.

After formation the new club had little money and was a selling club and trawling through the early years I can find no sign of a fee being paid for a player. By the season 1927/28 Pompey had reached the dizzy heights of the First Division and it was inevitable that money would have to be spent. In early 1928 a fee of £4,500 was paid to Falkirk for Centre Half John McIlwaine with the promise of a friendly at Fratton Park thrown in. McIlwaine made his debut at home to Sunderland on 18th February 1928 in a 5-3 defeat - not a good start for a new defender!! John played in all the remaining games that season as Pompey just avoided relegation. In all McIlwaine played 62 games scoring 5 goals before being sold to Southampton at a profit in June 1930.

Another eight years passed and Pompey really broke the bank by paying Irish club Belfast Celtic £6,000 for Inside Right Jimmy McAlinden on 15 December 1938. Jimmy went on to become one of the heroes of the 1939 Cup Final and played again for Pompey after the war before moving to Stoke City in 1947. McAlinden managed 9 goals in 59 games in Royal Blue. An attempt was made to bring him back in 1950 but the move ran into problems with Directors Vernon Stokes and Harry Wain being suspended for life over alleged irregularities. The ban was only lifted after a 25,000-signature petition from fans to the FA.

The next entry on our trip through record fees is the little known Albert Juliussen, a Centre Forward signed from Dundee for £10,500 in March 1948. Albert played only 7 times scoring 4 goals before being sold to Everton six months later.

The Championship was therefore won twice without any sizeable fee being paid for any player!! It was in June 1951 - memories (that is when I was born) that Pompey splashed another record on Left Winger Gordon Dale. Chesterfield received £20,000 for the popular player loved by many fans during the 50's. I saw Dale play for the ex Championship XI in the late 60's and he still had a wonderful touch. After 120 games and 18 goals Gordon moved on to Exeter in 1957 with the club beginning the slide from the pinnacle of English soccer.

In fact the fee paid for Dale was to stand for nearly sixteen years before another popular Left Winger would up the figure to a huge £25,000. Plymouth were the recipients of that fee in January 1967 for the diminutive Nicky Jennings. Nicky was a rarity, a goal scoring winger and my favourite memory of him was his hat-trick in a 3-1 win at Norwich in September 1967. In fact Nippy Nick was a key part of the impressive start to that season which saw us go ten games before the first defeat.

The 1967/68 season was the season that should have been, top at Christmas the club needed a goalscorer to secure promotion. Two names were mentioned - John O`Rourke went to Ipswich Town and Pompey paid a new record of £40,000 to Everton for their FA Cup winning hero of 1966 Mike Trebilcock in Jan 1968. Unfortunately Trebs did not score the goals expected and the blues finished fifth. Ipswich however had made the right decision and O'Rourke's goals won them promotion with QPR.

Trebilcock stayed four years before moving to Torquay United having scored 37 goals in 111 games. Jennings stayed until 1973 scoring an impressive 50 goals in 218 appearances, when he joined Aldershot.

And on to the Deacon era. So far we have featured only six players in a history of 70 years now in 1973 the record was about to be broken four times.

Firstly Ron Davies, a Welsh International Striker arrived from Southampton for £45,000 in April. Then in May Full Back Phil Roberts joined from Bristol Rovers for £55,000 and days later Peter Marinello, the former golden boy of football, came from Arsenal for a massive £100,000. Fans could not believe it and when the three appeared in Albert McCann's testimonial later that month 22,000 rushed through the gates to see their new side. West Ham were beaten 4-2 on an entertaining night and expectations were high that the next season would bring glory at last - it was Pompey's 75th Anniversary season too.

But it all went wrong and results would not come and in December Deacon made a further attempt by paying Orient £154,000 for impressive Centre Back Paul Went and a smaller fee to Leicester City for fellow defender Malcolm Manley. With a new defence results and performances began to improve but at Notts County after only 10 games Manley suffered a severe knee injury and never played again. Pompey were out the cup the next week at neighbouring Forest and finished 15th after spending all that money.

Ron Davies left for Manchester United in 1974 in a swap for George Graham. Davies played 69 games netting 21 times. Marinello moved back to Scotland signing for Motherwell in 1975 making 106 appearance scoring 10 times and Went moved to Wales to join Cardiff in 1976 after 6 goals in 109 games.

Phil Roberts stayed the longest after converting to a utility player and winning four caps for his native Wales. He also went west to Hereford United in 1978 after 178 games scoring just the once in a Boxing Day 1975 win at Charlton.

Well that the end of Part one of this challenge. Part two soon when I have finished the research.

Written by eastneydave.

The views within this article are the views of the individual who wrote and submitted this piece, sometimes solely theirs. They are not necessarily shared by the Vital Pompey Site Journalists.

To join the Vital Pompey debate - in the forum or with comments on articles - simply take a few seconds to register an account.

Date:Tuesday September 18 2007
Time: 12:33PM


dave might not want to mention names - but i will, it was Chix asking the question... dave is a legend isnt he, really enjoyed this read and look forward to reading part 2!
18/09/2007 12:35:00
Great article.
18/09/2007 14:17:00
Thats amazing fella! Great piece...
L L Blue
18/09/2007 15:41:00
ive never known a fella with so much knowledge of the game - i know my stuff but this is only recent history, dave's a legend!
18/09/2007 16:20:00
Dave fantastic mate, your knowledge is amazing, we should have a regular feature of Ask Dave to see if we can beat you. Look forward to reading the next part.
18/09/2007 20:28:00
Enjoyed that dave!!
18/09/2007 21:18:00
All i can remember about the Deacons is me Dad being Furious that (he felt) John Deacon had splashed all the money from the football into the basketball team. Is this correct Dave??
18/09/2007 21:20:00
Excellent stuff...What about a 'WHERE ARE THEY NOW' segment. I can tell you that the Mike Trebilcock mentioned in this article is currently coaching young lads in DARWIN, Northern Territory, Australia. I still keep the photo of me taken with him at a Sportsman's dinner in Sydney around 1991. The Cornishman with a nose for goals was said about him when he equalised against Arsenal in an FA Cup game back in 1970 in front of some 40,000 fans at Fratton (inc me). We lost the replay 3-2 with 10 men and guess what, Arsenal when on to win the cup !!
19/09/2007 01:25:00
Dave - I've not read the article yet (but have viewed the comments) ... I'm off for a couple of days but when back I plan to sit down with a pint and take it all in - The amount of work you must have put in demands respect .. I will keep it warm and respond in full in a couple of days ..but i just know it's gonna beexcellent
19/09/2007 01:41:00
pompeygray, the where are they now is a great idea and something we should impliment - how do you fancy getting the ball rolling by maybe knocking something together and forwarding it to me as an article?
19/09/2007 09:56:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

A balanced side

Yes, there has been some criticism of Kenny Jackett and Pompey this season, but three points at Fleetwood on Tuesday is something we could all be pleased with.

Red & Yellow & Oh I'm Off...Portsmouth v Blackpool (24/2/18)

The Football League have now announced the Match Day officials that will take charge of the game between Portsmouth and Blackpool this Saturday.

On this day in history...22nd February

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd February.

On this day in history...21st February

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st February.

Portsmouth Archived Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Fleetwood MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Ronan0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

10.Dorking Pompey7
The Vital Football Members League