Vital Football

The 5 Sub Rule: To 'keep or not to 'keep?

The 5 Sub Rule: To 'keep or not to 'keep?
This week we learned that the upcoming season will see something a ruling change that will come as nothing new to us Pompey fans; that the substitutes bench this season in the Championship will only contain 5 players, reduced from the allotted 7 from last season (the FA and Carling Cup will remain at 7). Of course, due to our small squad, this will probably affect other clubs a lot more than us.

But with this in mind, I brought up the thought of how this might take effect on new tactics in terms of what positions a manager could/should name for maximum potential, and an interesting concept is making what is essentially an 'extra space' by forfeiting the obligatory space allotted for a sub keeper. Is this a risk that would pay off? Well I tried to answer my own question by fishing out my research hat and found the following statistics...

Over the last decade we have 13 goalkeepers, namely:

Sasa Ilic
Dave Beasant
Yoshikatsu Kawaguchi
Chris Tardiff
Shaka Hislop
Pavel Srnicek
Harald Wapenaar
Jamie Ashdown
Konstantinos Chalkias
Dean Kiely
Sander Westerveld
David James
Asmir Begovic

During that time they have played 396 games between them but only twice was there a need for a substitution to take place, with those occasions being.

(1). Shaka Hislop being replaced by Yoshi Kawaguchi vs Bradford on 04-05-2003: This substitution was pre-planned before the game, as Yoshi was appearing in what would be his last act for the club. There was no injury, it was done on merit alone. It was the last game of the season when we had already won the league. Wasn't a necessity and could have been arranged to have him on the bench before hand seen as it was planned.

(2). David James being replaced by Asmir Begovic vs Arsenal on 22-08-2009: David James had a slight injury to his left knee and was taken off with 15 minutes remaining when with the scoreline at 4-1 to Arsenal with upcoming domestic and International fixtures in mind. It was more precautionary that necessary, and if push came to shove he'd probably have been able to see out the last quarter of an hour.

That's it! A decade of games checked and they were the only two instances of this, and these both seemed totally avoidable.

So is it plausible that we should consider this tactic. Having 2 strikers, 2 midfielders (1 attacking and 1 defensive) and a defender on the bench seems a lot more resourceful than having to miss out on one of these players. In my own opinion the rewards greatly outweigh the risks here.

Another scenario is that our keeper receives a red card. It hasn't happened in my last decade of research, and to be honest, if it did happen, who's to say we hadn't used all 3 subs or been too far behind to make a difference anyway. As an emergency plan, I bet Halford is actually a decent 'keeper!

Of course, another rather large elephant in the room that I'm overlooking is our squad size might not cater for 5 subs in the first place, in which case this whole article is irrelevant, but for arguments sake let's pretend for now that we do have these resources.

Just something to ponder over, you may agree or disagree, but do share your opinion.

Written by PompeyFrippy.

The views within this article are the views of the individual who wrote and submitted this piece, sometimes solely theirs. They are not necessarily shared by the Vital Pompey Site Journalists.

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Trust

Writer:PompeyFrippy
Date:Saturday July 23 2011
Time: 9:33AM

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Adams Turns Professional

Comments

0
yea, this could work frippy. however just say: it's the last day of the season. pompey need a draw to get into the playoffs. its late in the game and ashdown gives away a penalty and is sent off. I know it's rather far fetched but i think in the very important games i would keep a sub keeper as a precaution.
Pompey-N.I
23/07/2011 10:11:00
0
i'm with Pompey-N.I here . in important games we could probably do with a sub goalie cos knowing our luck if we don't then our starting goalie (most probably ashdown) will most probably get injured or sent off
pompey4ever
25/07/2011 15:38:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Vital View - League 2, 21st January 2017

Doncaster and Plymouth strengthened their positions in automatic promotion places with wins. Notts County and Newport remain in the relegation places.

On this day in history...23rd January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 23rd January.

Sunday Chimes #101 - Pompey frozen off

No game but relief as Carlisle slip up, the transfer window and the return of the Grump......

On this day in history...22nd January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd January.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

What do we reckon - top 3 or play-offs?
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Top 3 - Carlisle will be caught100%
Play-offs - not consistent enough0%
With Pompey you can never tell!0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Doncaster 27 18 4 5 58 21
2 Plymouth 26 17 3 6 54 15
3 Carlisle 27 12 12 3 48 11
4 Portsmouth 26 13 6 7 45 14
5 Wycombe 26 12 7 7 43 6
6 Luton 26 11 9 6 42 13
7 Colchester 27 11 7 9 40 7
8 Barnet 27 10 10 7 40 0
9 Exeter 26 12 3 11 39 12
10 Cambridge 26 11 6 9 39 7
11 Grimsby 27 11 6 10 39 4
12 Mansfield 27 9 10 8 37 -1
13 Blackpool 26 9 9 8 36 11
14 Crawley 25 10 5 10 35 -7
15 Stevenage 27 10 3 14 33 -6
16 Yeovil 26 8 8 10 32 -3
17 Morecambe 25 9 4 12 31 -11
18 Hartlepool 27 7 9 11 30 -9
19 Crewe 27 6 10 11 28 -13
20 Accrington 26 6 8 12 26 -11
21 Leyton Orient 26 7 4 15 25 -11
22 Cheltenham 26 5 9 12 24 -11
23 Notts County 27 6 5 16 23 -22
24 Newport 26 4 7 15 19 -16
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Jan 28 2017 3:00PM : Exeter City (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 4 2017 3:00PM : Wycombe Wanderers (a)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 11 2017 3:00PM : Accrington Stanley (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 14 2017 7:45PM : Blackpool (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 18 2017 3:00PM : Barnet (a)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 25 2017 3:00PM : Carlisle United (a)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.pompeyrug53
2.uspompeyfan48
3.PompeyFrippy44
4.storagematt32
5.Copnor4323
6.FrattonBlue22
7.PompeyFromtheUSA8
8.pompeyweller8
9.steaming8
10.eastneydave7
Write for Vital Football