Vital Football

Pompey in for Derby's Giles Barnes?

Pompey in for Derby's Giles Barnes?

Giles Barnes is the golden boy of Derby, he helped them to promotion to the promised land, but since then has struggled with injury - he was even injured during the play off semi final win over the Saints last season, but was still fit enough to see them off.

He has made his return recently, but despite fending off summer interest from West Ham he looks destined to leave Pride Park in January, but West Ham seem to have dropped out of the race?

Villa were strongly linked with him at the tail end of the weekend, with them reportedly now being joined by City and Pompey, so a battle to land the England U21 star is said to be ready to begin in the new year.

Barnes is a class act, and in his limited appearance in the top flight - added to that what I saw of him in the Championship - he does not look out of place but would he fit into the set up at Pompey though? Even with the African nations we still appear to have enough in midfield to cover this.

That said though another bright young English talent coming to Pompey would not be a bad thing would it, at 19 he has a good 15 years or so of his very best to offer yet doesn't he...

As I say I am not so sure, I would not say no, but is midfield an area that we really need to look at that much in January - as talented as he is the reported £5m fee could be spent elsewhere strengthening the side couldn't it?

PLAY UP POMPEY!

To join the Vital Pompey debate - in the forum or with comments on articles - simply take a few seconds to register an account.

Writer:pompeyrug
Date:Tuesday December 11 2007
Time: 8:00AM

Comments

0
Got to be honest....don't remember ever having seen the lad play. He's young, he's English = 'Arry won't put him in the team. ...one for the future apparently...
Tantona
11/12/2007 09:16:00
0
i think its a misconception that 'arry doesnt give young english talent a chance... he might not do it so much at pompey but he did this all the time at west ham didnt he and also did this with the lot down the road didnt he?
pompeyrug
11/12/2007 11:57:00
0
True Rug......Harry's record in bringing on young English talent at West Ham was great; Ferdinand, Lampard, Joe Cole, Carrick, Defoe etc.
NinjaTim
11/12/2007 13:33:00
0
Prospects are great, but don't we already have one Championship superstar sitting on the bench waiting for his bus to stardom ? - Lets get someone with some experience, i.e. Crouch, Kanoute, Lita etc.
Toronto4Pompey
11/12/2007 13:57:00
0
You know me I love the young prospects, but you do have a good point in that the money could be spent on a quality player that could give us a boost immediately. It all depends on how much money is available and who will go come january
whitestones
11/12/2007 15:43:00
0
id prefer to see us keep matty than buy giles barnes, but he is probably the most talked about 19 year old in the premiership (other than fabregas) so he cant be bad...
jbaker
11/12/2007 16:58:00
0
injuries are something we should also look at, and if we need him. utaka is gonna be around for some time and we have kranjcar too on the right, with gutierrez being looked at too! we dont want another songo'o (right wonger who never even gets considered), who incidently i really want to see play as iv only heard good things about him!
jbaker
11/12/2007 17:00:00
0
Have to agree with you totally jbaker, Keep Matty and spend the money else where. Songoo by the way, nice footballer. played alright every time ive seen him anyway.
pentonpompey
11/12/2007 17:26:00
0
As well as buying for our immediate needs we have to keep on eye on the future .. I don't like the fact that he's had more than the 'odd' injury but I definately think we should looking at him seriously... Derby will need to raise cash and this is one sure way to do it .... I say yes... as long as we get the striker and winger we need as well
Chix
11/12/2007 18:26:00
0
I agree chixy, its all depends on the finances available, if 3 quality players without losing any (notably matty or Nuge) then i'm all for getting him, i think he has a bright future
whitestones
11/12/2007 20:10:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Portsmouth Articles

FA End Betting Sponsorship

Late yesterday afternoon, the Football Association announced the result of its three month review of their relationship with gambling companies and that association now comes to an end.

No new Pompey deal for Hunt

Noel Hunt, signed on a one year deal after leaving Southend last summer, which came after spells at the likes of Reading, Leeds and Ipswich, isn't in Pompey's future plans.

Done and dusted - Pompey sign Swindon's Thompson

Out-of-contract at the County Ground, Thompson was offered a new deal at Swindon but opted to end to his Robins career after League One relegation. He signed a two year deal at Pompey.

Davies to Tranmere as Blues close in on Thompson?

With Burgess, Clarke and Whatmough ahead of him Davies' chances at Pompey are limited, especially if Swindon's Thompson completes move to Fratton Park - Davies could join Tranmere?

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Thoughts on Jackett's first signing Nathan Thompson
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Happy, we needed another right back32%
Disappointed, not good enough0%
Unsure, need to see more of him7%
I'll trust Jackett's judgement61%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.pompeyrug78
2.eastneydave27
3.PompeyFrippy20
4.Copnor4313
5.penton6
6.mslorna486
7.storagematt6
8.stubbsy0073
9.pompeyweller3
10.robertpog3
Vital Football Comment