UK time is: 04:55:20
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

4-4-2 should be the Fratton way

I would prefer to see Pompey play matches at Fratton in a 4-4-2 formation! Not my vote, yours - although these findings from pompey4me's poll are thoughts that I share.

Harry Redknapp again tried his 4-3-3 formation against Liverpool and although it was not anywhere near as disappointing as it was when it was used again United I still cannot help but think it is not really the right way to go - particularly at home - and tends to waste the qualities of some players, most noticeable Benjani.

I am a fan of the 4-4-2, yep it is simple and traditional but it has served us well and is a formation that in my own opinion we should be using for matches at Fratton, something that a lot seem to agree with.

To be honest I would not mind playing with a 3-5-2 if we could, but the players do not feel they could play in such a formation. Matty Taylor and Glen Johnson would be idea, as they could get up and down the pitch all day long, but then it would mean others missing out in their best positions, so they might be 'accommodated' in lesser roles.

We could argue all day long bout what formation or personnel should or should not be used, but Redknapp will keep doing what he feels best, so as long as this works more often than not we will be happy.

What the poll asked - What formation do you think Pompey should play at home?

How you voted - 4-4-2 62%, 3-5-2 17%, 4-3-3 13%, Other formation that players nor fans will understand! 4%, 4-2-4 1%, 4-5-1 1%, 4-3-2-1 1%, 3-3-4 1%

Current Poll - Pompey gained 6 points from the opening 6 games, but with United, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool out of the way - which yielded only 2 points, when we should have earned at least 5 - after this weekend against Blackburn, which will be very difficult, we come up against teams that we should be beating.

Most people expected a difficult start to the season, so the points tally would have been about par for them, my own expectations were higher than this though to be honest, but on the whole we have performed well so as long as we push on from this we can still have a fine season, starting with the next 6 games, mostly all winnable one, but how well could we do, this is what pompeycarpet wants to know with this - 'How many points will Pompey get in there next 6 games?' Let the poll do the talking before we do when it finishes.

PLAY UP POMPEY!

To join the Vital Pompey debate - in the forum or with comments on articles - simply take a few seconds to register an account.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

The Journalist

Writer: pompeyrug Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday September 20 2007

Time: 8:38AM

Your Comments

SHOULD. Yes it should be!
storagematt
This is a debate that could go on for years. We actually finally have a big enough squad to rotate player and play different formations against differnt teams. If I wanted to play my opinion of the best team the formation would be 5-5-3! That's the difficulty. I'm not sure I envy Harry now he has to make the choices. We have been so used to it being a starting 11 with pretty dodgy reserves! lol
sneakay
When you have so many players available it tests both the managers tactical abilities and man management skills. It will test both of HRs in the coming months.
eastneydave
it certainly will. tbh it is easy for us to say this and that from the stands isnt it, but it is not as easy when you are the boss... i would still play 4-4-2 tho :)
pompeyrug
it has taken time to adjust, and we are still not perfect - the arsnal game prooved that - B, HR is...aparantly...good at man management, and we have always played nice football. As we were last season, and despite my hopes against derby, we are going to be short of goals this season, unless nuggent does what i beleive he can, and Harry moves Kanu back to a sub...and playes Utaka wide right...and matty wide left...defensivly, we are back to how we should be - seemless.
pompeycarpet
...and now for a controvseial tstatement, that comes from my naiivity...Now chelski dont have Morinhio, and considering there poor start- and spurs poor start, it has been suggested to me that we couldmount a decent challenge, not just for Uefa, but for champs league. (my friend is a neutral, and based what he said on what he has seen...or atleast, thats what he claims...). in some way, it follows, that if we just miss out on relegation, then we just miss out on uefa cup...this season, we will just miss out on champs league...roll on next season :P
pompeycarpet
I will miss Jose, he was good fun, and made me smile, and i dont think he will be out the game for long. We need to improve dramatically if we are to mount a challenge for the top 10, and we need to score goals, lots of them. We have Sol and Sylvain at the back with Jammo, and the spine is carried on by the decent midfield, minus bloody Davis.
Owenspompey
...im actually gettin quite annoted with this now...Davis is not actually a bad playor. Sure, he wont make our starting XI, but that is because we have better playors, not because he is bad. He lacks a little creativity, but puts in effort, and can ttackle, so i dont see why eeryone is getting on his back...sorry about the rant, it was just starting to REALLY annoy me...
pompeycarpet
you say davis wont make our starting 11 carpet man, but he seems to be doing a pretty good job of it as 'arry has starting in in almost every match so far... unless you meant 'our' as in the fans starting 11. dont get me wrong i quite like davis, but we have nothing creative in our midfield, we need a mendes or a kranjcar to come in and play alongside muntari - keep him in the middle 'arry, not on the left - or diop, maybe both as 'arry likes, david works tirelessly but we need that creative spark in midfield and some goals to go with it... davis should have had at least 2 goals already this season as he has missed a couple of sitters, the one at arsenal was the worse... during the summer i was all for keeping him, but if anyone had to go i wanted it to have been him, as we know it was a favourite son...
pompeyrug
Back to the poll, plain ans simple, it should be 4-4-2!!!! Personally dont see the bad in Davies, quite like him, wouldnt start him every week, certainally wouldnt drop Mendes for him, but thats footie, still a game of opinions! Kranjcar and Taylor must be getting pretty *****ed off now, Kranjcar hardley plays and MT seems to of *****ed Harry off again.
pompey4me
by "my" startin XI, i mean that if i were manager, i would not play him - although he is good to have in the squad! I like the fella, but with the arrival of muntari, and the progession of kranjcar, he just isnt creative enough to start a game. sure, Harry plays him, but that could just be him trying to put together a more defensive line up, if he sees davis as a more defensive player than the others.
pompeycarpet
i fear that matty taylor is going to leave in january fellas - and tbh i wouldnt blame him... i worry about mendes too, kranchie doesnt worry me so much, but i always see him as less affective on the left - but it looks as tho that is where 'arry will play him if/when he does...
pompeyrug
by saying 'doesnt worry me so much' i do not mean i dont mind if he goes, as i would, i mean i dont have any fears that he will go just yet... altho tbh my view has been that the 1st sign of interest from a top, top club and he might go, whereas matty taylor wouldnt have - but i think he might now if he gets the chance?
pompeyrug
matty needs to play more games if we want to keep him. at the moment, he is only getting depressed, the fans are getting depressed, and when he does play, he is trying too hard to show his worth to the team, by shooting from everywhere. give the guy a run in the team, and we will see the matty we love, leave him out, and he will be off in a flash. Krunchie and muntari are both wasted on the left, so we need to keep matty!!!
pompeycarpet
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Portsmouth Articles

On this day in history...21st December (Sunday December 21 2014)

Stats: Cheltenham v Pompey (Saturday December 20 2014)

On this day in history...20th December (Saturday December 20 2014)

#PompeyPredictionsLeague - Update no.20 (Friday December 19 2014)

Cheltenham v Pompey - Thoughts? (Friday December 19 2014)

Tranmere rearranged for Feb (Friday December 19 2014)

Cheltenham v Pompey - early team news (Friday December 19 2014)

On this day in history...19th December (Friday December 19 2014)

An unwanted Christmas present... (Thursday December 18 2014)

Archived Portsmouth Articles

List All Vital Pompey Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. pompeyrug 84
2. eastneydave 31
3. storagematt 31
4. cornypomp 30
5. gentleman jim 19
6. Emsworthianblue 19
7. Jimsmithswig 17
8. mslorna48 15
9. Copnor43 11
10. PFCblue 6

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
11. Accrington 21 9 3 9 -3 30
12. Cambridge 21 8 5 8 7 29
13. Stevenage 21 8 4 9 -1 28
14. Portsmouth 21 7 6 8 -1 27
15. Wimbledon 21 7 6 8 -3 27
16. Mansfield 21 7 5 9 -8 26
17. Oxford 21 6 7 8 -3 25

Breaking League News

City Ladies Reserves held
York : 21/12/2014 18:52:00
Coker Chuffed To Be Back
Southend : 21/12/2014 18:01:00
Archer Heading Back To Spurs
Northampton : 21/12/2014 17:24:00
Waterfall Would Love To Stay
Mansfield : 21/12/2014 17:17:00
Hartlepool Dismiss Evans Reports
Hartlepool : 21/12/2014 17:11:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Cheltenham?
Suggested By:  pompeyrug
Jones 0%
Devera 0%
Robinson 0%
Whatmough 0%
Butler 0%
Bean 0%
Hollands 0%
Wallace 100%
Atangana (84) 0%
Holmes 0%
Taylor 0%
Sub - Barcham (84) 0%