UK time is: 02:24:56
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Best defender (Pompey or not) you've ever seen?

Having seen this, a question of the day on The Ivory FC - Nivea for men Great Football Experiment (here) - vital site I thought why not throw it open to you guys here on Vital Pompey too?

After all, lets face it there is not really much going on is there as we wait for our new manager, something we could be waiting for yet for a while to come!

QOTD: Best Defender You've Ever Seen? - Here.

This is what the article said...

Last time we met up with Ray Wilkins we had a really good chat about all things football. I then asked him, as you would expect, who the best player he ever played with was. His response, in an instant, was Franco Baresi when he was at AC Milan. He then regaled us with stories a plenty, my favourite of which was letting Karl Heinz Rummenigge have a head start in a game at the San Siro, before laughing at him, running after him and then winning the ball with consummate ease.

This got me thinking. We've spoken about favourite players, favourite goals and other things which no doubt favour the more attacking, creative player. But how about those the stop the goals from being scored? A focus last night at training was around us defending better as a unit. Yes we are good going forward but defensively we can still improve.

I wont necessarily limit this to players you've seen play live, but I always feel that there is so much more you can see around a players ability when you watch them at the stadium. Their movement off the ball, their positional sense etc. For me the best defender I have seen was Jaap Stam.

He is one of the only players that Ferguson has said he regrets selling and he's one of the few players I have been genuinely gutted that we let go. Yes he looked average when we first signed him but once he found his feet he was class. His movement, his awareness, his strength, his pace, his ability in the air, his tackling - all of it, for me at least, were first class and he was a joy to watch. If I am honest I don't think he is held in as a high a regard as he should be.

So, come on lads, best defender you've seen?


Interesting debate to be had here is there not with so many views and opinions that could be shared. As the article itself says few actually pay as much attention to 'the art of defending' as it is the attacking prowess that catches the imagination more.

Go on guys, who is 'the best defender you've seen', be that Pompey and/or otherwise?

Let us know with some comments below and also share these thoughts on The Ivory FC GFE website as well please, a quick copy and paste onto this link would be appreciated!

QOTD: Best Defender You've Ever Seen? - Here.

PLAY UP POMPEY!

Click here to make your prediction: Derby v Pompey.
Click here to make your prediction: Palace v Pompey.

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Vital Pompey on: facebook Vital Pompey on: twitter

Join the Vital Pompey Forum Debate

Frippy's Virtual Bookies - here.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: pompeyrug Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday October 26 2011

Time: 11:13PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
we have seen some VERY good defenders at pompey over the years, in more recent years some top class international ones but the likes of symons and awford were from my 'early days'. thought linvoy was something else and actually outshone sol for a while, with distin also quality but think i would just about go de zeeuw as my best in a pompey shirt...

best defender fullstop, maldini was fantastic and consistently good for, what, 20-years - so you cannot look too far past him, but moore was up there for a few years and you have beckenbauer. from those i have seen i would say baresi is a good shout but would go maldini.
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
26/10/2011 23:20:00

Good question Rug - I am not going international for my answers though. The best Pompey defender was in my book Malcolm Manley - only a short career but he oozed class on the ball and always had time even on some very poor surfaces - Swindon FA Cup replay 1974 as my evidence. So sad that he picked up that injury at Notts County after so few games.

Away from Pompey I would have to go for Des Walker. If Brian Clough said he was the best then that is good enough for me!!
eastneydave
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 07:53:00

I think Sol Campbell would be right up there, obviously in his pre Pompey days (he was past his best when he came to us but still a great signing)
Steve C
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 08:28:00

picking out an individual for me is near impossible, esp when the pairings of old were so good (bruce & pallister, bould, adams & keown etc) but if i had to pick 1,,,, i would have to say jaap stamm for his all round toughness and skill.
pfc,steve
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 10:51:00

I agree with Eastney, was tempted by Gavin Maguire but Manley edges it. He did not gwt sent off as far as I can remember
MickTait
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 12:55:00

Bobby Moore
uktony
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 13:12:00

Dejan, not bad at left back either, Younis was quite useful, Glen's best days were with us. de Zeeuw or Blake, not Campbell. Tindall even had a go in goal. Seem to remember George Ley got best looking defender one season. Linvoy was a legend Nope, it has to be de Zeeuw.
Ihatemidweektvgames
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 15:00:00

de zeeuw with linvoy a close second very underated. we've had a few good ones went, manley, cambell, foster
robertpog
Report Abuse
27/10/2011 22:28:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Portsmouth Articles

What a waste... (Sunday April 19 2015)

Video highlights - Pompey 0-1 Bury (Sunday April 19 2015)

Stats: Portsmouth v Bury (Saturday April 18 2015)

On this day in history...18th April (Saturday April 18 2015)

Pompey v Bury - Fratton (Friday April 17 2015)

Worthington wants it! (Friday April 17 2015)

Archived Portsmouth Articles

List All Vital Pompey Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. pompeyrug 165
2. Pompeytim 39
3. eastneydave 34
4. cornypomp 30
5. storagematt 30
6. Et_tu_Pompeii 28
7. PFCblue 21
8. mslorna48 19
9. Jimsmithswig 19
10. Copnor43 19

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
13. Wimbledon 44 14 15 15 -4 57
14. Dag & Red 44 16 8 20 -4 56
15. Oxford 44 13 16 15 -2 55
16. Portsmouth 44 13 14 17 -3 53
17. Accrington 44 14 11 19 -16 53
18. Cambridge 44 13 12 19 -2 51
19. York 44 11 18 15 -3 51

Breaking League News

Penney Looks For Bury Momentum
Southend : 20/04/2015 19:37:01
Leonard amp; Timlin Talk Exeter amp; Bury
Southend : 20/04/2015 19:19:00
Brown Set For Three Year Deal
Southend : 20/04/2015 19:11:01
Determined Exeter Performance For Brown
Southend : 20/04/2015 19:06:00
Leutwiler's Record Delight
Shrewsbury : 20/04/2015 18:52:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Bury MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Jones 3%
Devera 11%
Webster 11%
Nosworthy 0%
Shorey 5%
Atangana 0%
Hollands 0%
Close 11%
Wallace 38%
Tubbs 0%
Westcarr 5%
Sub - Ertl 5%
Sub - Chaplin 0%
Sub - May 11%