Vital Football

Mullins hard done by?

Mullins hard done by?

Pompey's appeal against Hayden Mullins' sending off against Coventry on Tuesday has failed.

By all accounts the club were pretty confident that this would be overturned although following an appeal to the FA this was not the case with Steve Cotterill, as he told The Pompey Site, having this to say: 'I'm obviously disappointed. The lads here had put together a really good case.

'I didn't think it was even a penalty, but that's the second time in three games that I think we have been harshly treated.'

As a result Mullins will sit out the Cardiff game tomorrow.

You know what, we will miss the guy - now who would have thought any of us would have said something like that 12-15-months or so ago!

In missing this game he also loses his record as potentially going through the season as the only outfield player to feature in every game...

To be honest I have seen no footage of the incident, I only saw it as it happened and even then to say I 'saw it' would not be entirely true as I did not see the incident clearly at all - even so it sounds as though Mullins has been hard done by, not once but twice?

Once with the sending off and twice as this appeal has been thrown out...

So, what do you reckon guys. Was Mullins harshly treated and the appeal rejection double punishment, or was the right decision made on both counts?


  • Click here to make your prediction: Cardiff v Pompey.

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate


  • Frippy's Virtual Bookies - latest update and place your bets!

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Friday April 15 2011
    Time: 10:58AM


    its on the BBC site, hit his thigh onto his arm but as far as the appeal goes his arm not by his side and it does move, so letter of the law, penalty and sending off, harsh but ref not obviously wrong, on this decision anyway, to get decision overturned.
    15/04/2011 11:25:00
    But surely, once it hits his thigh it is no longer going goalwards. It may be a penalty, but a red card it is not. (A) It was not deliberate and (B) It wasn't going in, an obvious goalscoring opportunity was not stopped (ignoring the fact that Ashdown was right behind him ready to scoop up the loose ball)
    15/04/2011 11:41:00
    We would have called for it had it been Coventry, bit of a red herring this one and diflecting people from the fact that Pompey had enough chances but blew it yet again. You will check back and note that almost every time Cot loses it's down to the Ref; he's getting quite a rep in this league.
    15/04/2011 13:51:00
    still have not seen it but still, from what i hear, reckon he was hard done by but hey ho you move on...
    cotts MUST stop blaming everyone else bar himself/the players (at least certain player in particular) for defeats.
    15/04/2011 16:24:00
    I had a good view of the incident and Frippy is absolutely right. Ashdown was on hand and the ball would not have gone in. It was ball to hand alright but was not a sending off or a penalty so what is the point of an appeals procedure then?
    15/04/2011 21:11:00
    Right Dave, the only point of an appeal, is to pay a bunch of idiots just to make teams suffer another ban for the appeal, but not this time, so they know their wrong.
    16/04/2011 09:17:00
    Page 1/1
    1. 1

    Login to post a comment

    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    Another Fratton disappointment

    That 2nd half on Saturday against Notts County was woeful - absolutely awful wasn't it. The first 15-minutes or so of it was like a pre-season friendly to pre-season!

    Match highlights - Pompey 1-2 Notts County

    What a disappointment that was! The 1st half wasn't bad, in fact large chunks of it were good but the 2nd half was just woeful with a soft centred Pompey beaten 2-1 by Notts County.

    On this day in history...24th October

    A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 24th October.

    Audio - Cook Talks County Defeat

    Manager Paul Cook has been speaking of his disappointment following defeat to Notts County this weekend.

    Archived Vital Pompey Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    Editor email
    Editor email
    no email
    no email

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Notts County MotM
    Suggested By: Site Staff
    Sub - Naismith0%
    Sub - Main0%
    Sub - Lalkovic0%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

    League Table

    # Team P W D L Pts. GD
    1 Plymouth 14 10 2 2 32 12
    2 Carlisle 14 7 7 0 28 10
    3 Doncaster 14 8 2 4 26 8
    4 Luton 14 6 5 3 23 9
    5 Portsmouth 14 6 3 5 21 6
    6 Notts County 14 6 3 5 21 1
    7 Accrington 14 5 5 4 20 1
    8 Grimsby 14 6 2 6 20 0
    9 Crawley 14 5 5 4 20 -1
    10 Morecambe 14 6 2 6 20 -6
    11 Mansfield 14 4 7 3 19 1
    12 Crewe 14 4 7 3 19 -1
    13 Yeovil 14 6 1 7 19 -5
    14 Blackpool 14 4 5 5 17 4
    15 Colchester 14 4 5 5 17 -1
    16 Cheltenham 14 3 7 4 16 -1
    17 Hartlepool 14 3 7 4 16 -4
    18 Cambridge 14 4 4 6 16 -5
    19 Leyton Orient 14 4 3 7 15 -2
    20 Barnet 13 3 6 4 15 -4
    21 Wycombe 14 4 3 7 15 -5
    22 Stevenage 13 4 2 7 14 -3
    23 Exeter 14 4 1 9 13 -6
    24 Newport 12 1 4 7 7 -8
    The Vital Football Members League
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    Vital Football Comment

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

    Oct 29 2016 3:00PM : Cambridge United (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Nov 12 2016 3:00PM : Mansfield Town (H)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Nov 19 2016 3:00PM : Cheltenham Town (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Nov 22 2016 7:45PM : Luton Town (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Nov 26 2016 3:00PM : Stevenage (H)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Grimsby Town (a)
    Sky Bet League Two

    Vital Members League Table

    Write for Vital Football