Vital Football

Why be surprised?

Why be surprised?

If anyone can honestly put their hand on their heart and tell me that they did, or still do, expect Dave Nugent to still be a Pompey player next season then I would be surprised.

Lets face it the guy has to be on at least £20,000 p/w although I still feel it is nearer the £30,000, and I know this is a debate that has raged for ages, so with a need to shave off around 50% of that for a new contract it was/is never gonna happen, right?

Steve Cotterill has said, and he seems to take it quite personally, that he feels it will be a shame following all the time and effort that has been put in with him this season to, almost it seems from what he says, 'make him the player he has become' if he then upped sticks and left when his contract ends.

He 'might' be enjoying his football and he 'might' even be pretty happily settled into life with Portsmouth Football Club these days but what it ALL boils down to, for the vast majority of players these days, is money and if so much needs to be reduced from a current salary it is near on a dead certainty that he will go to another club that offers more.

To be honest, for all his work ethic and enthusiasm the ability that Nugent needs to be a regular at a 'decent' premier league clubs makes it unlikely that he would ever play for one, regularly at least, that will always be safely secured of a place in the top flight so a lower end side, 'probably' flirting with relegation most the time is where he would end up for me.

With all due respect to these clubs, the likes of Wigan, Blackpool and maybe Wolves - should any or all remain in the premier league - would be the ones that looked at him, then again how much would they pay him?

£10,000, maybe £15,000 tops?

So, not 'really' much more than we could or would I suspect but enough to make a difference, to him and an agent, plus he has the tag of being a 'premier league footballer' again.

'Perhaps' Nugent will still surprise me, well many of us, and opt to sign a new deal on reduced wages, although lets not start banking on it and instead of being overly concerned by it - as nothing can be said or done to change his mind if it is made up - lets, as GoldenBoot recently said in the forum, start looking at new options for next season ourselves.

If we look long and hard enough 'surely' we could find a striker as effective as Nugent, but on a much lesser wage and at a nominal, if not free, fee...

All of this said 'if' we can pull off, what would be a monumental achievement, a play-off spot and go back up again I would 'think' that his mind would soon change!

What are your thoughts on the Dave Nugent contract situation guys? Share them below...


  • Click here to make your prediction: Pompey v Sheff Utd.

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate


  • Frippy's Virtual Bookies - latest update and place your bets!

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Wednesday March 2 2011
    Time: 4:09PM


    Rug, that's why the man is known as Potty Cottey. No one in their right mind believed Nugent would stay at the end of the season, being fair to Favid Nugent is on £26kpw. DL must tear his hair out at the managers pronouncements. It's simples if Nuge can get within the £10k - £15k per week ( I think the latter is the real figure) then that's great if not good luck and thanks for sticking around to give us some sort of minimal return on £6million.
    02/03/2011 16:36:00
    Being fair to David Nugent here, he has always said he would stick around to the end of the season 1) because he felt that he was getting his confidence back and 2) because the club had asked him to do that thing. Nugent didn't answer Ollie's call and run for the wages and we can't deny his commitment since he made that decision. So I don't begrudge him what ever decision he makes, same way I don't begrudge the club for defending it's financial structure.
    02/03/2011 16:41:00
    As the game last night showed Nuggett needs more chances for each goal than i believe is acceptable to a Prem team, and as for his control, dry pitch or not "he can trap it further than i can kick it" springs to mind. If he wants just to play football i think he will stay, if his agent says he is still homesick he will go, and probably to a relagated prem team from Up North
    02/03/2011 16:45:00
    If we are not prepared to go anywhere with Brown, Hughes, etc, which I am not complaining about it does say something about our negotiating skill (DL). As such alas my friends how can he stay? Unless we somehow manage to pay him as much as DK, LLor even AM
    02/03/2011 16:49:00
    I still don't think he can cut it in the Premiership just yet. Fair enough, he scores goals if given enough chances, but realistically, how many chances is he going to get at the likes of Wolves or Wigan?
    02/03/2011 18:00:00
    Of course we just might get back to the Prem. via the play-offs (unlikely I know) and this would change the equation considerably. Mick Tait, not sure exactly what you are saying there. On the one hand you say you are not complaining about the Brown and Hughes situation but you then have a go at DL's negotiating skills and salary. If Brown and Hughes won't budge it's got nothing to do with negotiating skills and everything to do with money. The club would be mad to play either of them if it means having to pay them another years's worth of inflated salary. If I was them I'd rather take a pay cut and play football but obviously money is more important to them than football, so that's that isn't it?
    02/03/2011 18:11:00
    I think Brown and Hughes attitude is disgusting. After all, we aren't fighting for breadline money here. Its Shall I get the Ferrarri this year or next year type money. As someone who worked the day she was old enough to - 13, and had a fulltime and a part time job until I went into business, I feel ashamed for them, I really do. I hope Nugent stays, the reasoning above makes sense, so it is not as unlikely as all that, I don't think.
    02/03/2011 18:55:00
    Let's not get too hung up on Nugget. Ok he's scored some goals for us and I'm pleased but heh! prolific goal scorer he most certainly ain't, and he's costing. I think some Pompey supporters ought to sit down and watch a video of his misses, many clear cut guilt edged chances laid on a plate.... they'd be horrified. There are others out there who can do a job for us on wages we can afford.
    02/03/2011 19:01:00
    That was watch a video of his "misses" by the way... not Mrs :-)
    02/03/2011 19:24:00
    got to say i agree corny. nugent offers us alot with his work rate, effort and enthusiasm altho for the money he is on his goals return, from the chances he has, 'could' maybe even 'should' be better - there ARE players out there who would command far less and score, which strikers are judged on really, a better ratio from chances they get...
    if the deal suits PFC then tie him down, problem is the deal that suits us will not suit him, unless we do go up again!
    03/03/2011 09:13:00
    Page 1/2
    1. 1
    2. 2

    Login to post a comment

    Best of International Football News

    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    On this day in history...21st February

    A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st February.

    Stats: Fleetwood Town v Portsmouth

    All the stats from Fleetwood Town (1) vs (2) Portsmouth, Highbury Stadium, 20/1/18 Att: 2,561

    Fleetwood v Portsmouth - Team Sheets (20/2/18)

    Fleetwood Town are at Highbury Stadium with Portsmouth the visitors today, this is a 7.45pm kick-off - the line-ups have been confirmed.

    Follow Fleetwood v Pompey Live On Twitter - 20/2/18

    Portsmouth travel to Fleetwood Town at Highbury Stadium today, this will be a 7.45pm kick-off.

    Portsmouth Archived Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    Editor email
    Editor email

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Fleetwood MotM
    Suggested By: Site Staff
    Sub - Ronan0%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
    Vital Football Comment
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    Write for Vital Football

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures

    Vital Members League Table

    10.Dorking Pompey7
    The Vital Football Members League