Vital Football

Positive, but don't get too involved Steve!

Positive, but don't get too involved Steve!

I have been quite 'concerned' by the level of negativity by Steve Cotterill towards the youth at this club, and more to the point the way they have been brushed aside as 'not being good enough' from the off...

Ok, to be fair, there is a good chance that a number - maybe all - will not make it but to completely write them off, especially given our situation, has been quite baffling at times.

Then again is the price of what we have previously been paying these kids, and what we have to continue to pay the senior ones, meaning that these have to be sacrificed in order to 'attempt' to make ends meet, proved our undoing here?

I would say that my biggest concern, good enough or not, with the youth situation is that these kids are being brushed aside with little, or no, thought being given with the 'longer-term' in mind...

By this I mean the season end.

When this arrives I would 'think' that any senior player, on good money, that is out of contract will be shown the door. Any other senior, or player of any note, that is still on money that is beyond a sustainable amount would also be looked to move on and that is not forgetting the loanees that will return to their parent club.

This is all part of 'stabilising' and 'rebuilding' the club, so these tough decision need to be made and accepted as such.

But then the biggest concern is that we will be left with a squad, the ones contracted to Portsmouth Football Club, of around a dozen players as a result, if that!

It would be foolhardy to think that we will have an 'easy' task of attracting players here, free agent or otherwise because we will not be offering money that others could...

So, even though some of these kids 'might' not be good enough 'perhaps' we should have been thinking that 'maybe' that is what we had to make do with, like it or not, good enough or not?

Again, as I and others have said, some of these kids have been on money WELL above what they should be, and if that is the case - and they genuinely are not good enough - then I guess the right call was made but I think writing them all off now is a foolish move because youngsters can, and many do, improve given time and time is what we have to give them.

Look at Joel Ward for example, he was written off by Cotterill, but fortunately - even if it was by default - he has proven him wrong, as I still feel Matty Ritchie would have, although I think the move to Swindon is also as much about what is best for him as anything and this move will give him the regular football he wants.

Writing off Marlon Pack, again maybe he might not make this level, is another strange one as, if nothing else, being used as a squad player is something that he could surely have been to have added something next season without being on too much money to boot?

Every squad needs those players that are good, but perhaps not quite good enough to command a starting place week-in-week out, but will do a job when called upon - who is to say that he would not have been one of them...

Nadir Ciftci is another we have to be careful with. Granted I can sometimes see where Cotterill is coming from with him but if he is handled and nurtured the right way we can get something out of him, as I feel we can Tom Kilbey.

A constant amount of saying 'they are not ready' and 'I do not know if they will' is not going to help, some level of diplomacy needs to start being shown by Cotterill methinks.

All this said it pleases me that Cotterill wants to have a revamp of the youth set-up here, as I seriously feared we would 'scrap it' altogether. And this is not something we can afford to do as attempting to produce, and develop, our own players is paramount to our future, and us being able to even have one!

I also like the thought that he wants to get 'coaches out on the grass' with these kids to help develop, and hone, their ability more and does not just want people overseeing them from behind a desk with 'pen and paper'.

I dare say there are roles within this set-up that are not needed, so some can be dispensed of, I would also say that there are roles not being filled that need filling so we sort them too.

It also makes 'some sense' that Cotterill pays attention to this level, although I am not keen on him having too much of a hands on approach as I am not convinced that he handles the younger players in the right way - when all is said and done his job is as manager of the 1st team so he should do that, and focus mainly on that area.

Yep, keep an eye on youth level, a close eye - be it through one of your 1st team coaches, but let the coaches - and get them coaching - at such a level do what they are meant to be doing and most of all taking on the advise passed onto him about players' ability is something that he must do.

Starting to utilise players that we bring through ourselves, bringing them through in the right way, is something that - as said - is essential to PFC's future, so lets do this right, starting with this revamp being right...


  • Click here to make your prediction: Brighton v Pompey.

  • Click here to make your prediction: Forest v Pompey.

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate


  • Frippy's Virtual Bookies - latest update and place your bets!

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Thursday January 6 2011
    Time: 12:52PM


    Good article Ruggers.. although you know I disagree with most of it (lol). We have wasted a lot of money over the past ten years chasing youngsters who have not made the grade and we have had nothing to show for it (Wilson and Begovic apart .. although they weren't found by us!). With Paul Smalleys resignation we have a great opportunity to rethink and revamp and I am right behind SC on this one. Do we really want 'not good enough' players playing for us .. irrespective of age ?? - No more Subotics, Sowahs Mvembas or Cowen-Halls please. If we have a youth set-up let's not follow the Paul Hart route .. Despite all the accolades .. he produced zilch !.. Liam O'Brien signing for Barnet today really sums up my case - Not good enough and never will be. We need players who are good enough now and if we pick the best (ish) from L1 or L2 we will be able to afford them and they will already possess the experience SC craves
    06/01/2011 13:28:00
    Good article Rug. Happy new year Chix! I agree that Cot should concentrate on being a 1st team manager; too many tames have started with Pompey on the wrong tactical foot and that issue rests with the manager. It's quite odd this about face when Cot was instrumental in clowing down a system which ended up producing a few good players- ultimately for the stains - but Pompey in schools identified talent. I'm not sure Chixy's plan to stock up by buying an L2-3 player who has reached his peak in skill and experience a lower league is the way forward. That's been tried a few times before and tended to result in the team dropping to the skill and experience level of it's players.
    06/01/2011 13:39:00
    Thanks I think you speak for loads of us for every Ward e.t.c we have probably thad 10s if not 100s of Mvembas, who if my memmory serves correctly cost us £££££££££
    06/01/2011 13:49:00
    Chixy the point i keep trying to make, not sure it is coming across or no, is that 'not good enough players' are, or 'might' be what we have to make do with as when the loanees and out of contract players leave its not as easy as saying 'we will go out and get new players'. would it not be best, so long as they are not on unrealistic money for players of their age or ability - at least at that time - is it not better to at least try and have a squad as opposed to not having one when we return to pre-season training?
    i think that its vitally important that we, as a club, start thinking about a 'long-term plan' that involves doing our utmost to bring through our own players, on our reasonable terms, as gone are the days when we nip out and easily strengthen when we need to!
    lets get it right, and actually having coaches out there that can work with the kids and see then develop will help, making them work their way up to achieving something, and not being given a fortune from a teenage age, 'should' help them want it more but they have to feel that they have this chance of making it and that is where cotts needs to start making them feel more like they do not just constantly saying 'not good enough' without even having a look...
    06/01/2011 14:46:00
    what worries me most is next season we are gonna be left with 4 players in our squad and will will have toi start from scratch and by the time the season start we will have a team of players who have not even kicked a ball together ? when are we gonna have a good start to a seascon?
    06/01/2011 16:38:00
    Great read Rug and I agree with most of what you've said. The thing is that I don't want Cotterill to get too involved with the youth set up. I agree maybe some involvment is necessary but to be frank he has shown his attitude towards our best youth players so God knows what he is going to think of the rest of them!
    06/01/2011 18:30:00
    Page 1/1
    1. 1

    Login to post a comment

    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    Another right back targeted

    Pompey could still sign former Birmingham defender Caddis - who had been training with Blackburn this month - despite the transfer window closing as he's a free agent.

    On this day in history...23rd February

    A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 23rd February.

    More Reliable Than A League 2 Octopus? (22/2/17)

    Time for the new special computer that crunches the numbers to determine the final League Two positions for 2016/17.

    On this day in history...22nd February

    A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd February.

    Archived Vital Pompey Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    Editor email
    Editor email
    no email

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Barnet MotM
    Suggested By: Site Staff
    Sub - Rose0%
    Sub - Chaplin26%
    Sub - Baker0%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

    League Table

    # Team P W D L Pts. GD
    1 Doncaster 32 19 7 6 64 23
    2 Plymouth 31 19 4 8 61 17
    3 Carlisle 32 15 13 4 58 11
    4 Luton 32 14 11 7 53 18
    5 Portsmouth 31 15 7 9 52 16
    6 Exeter 32 15 5 12 50 16
    7 Colchester 32 13 8 11 47 7
    8 Mansfield 32 12 11 9 47 4
    9 Stevenage 32 14 4 14 46 1
    10 Wycombe 32 13 7 12 46 -1
    11 Barnet 32 11 12 9 45 -2
    12 Grimsby 32 12 8 12 44 0
    13 Cambridge 31 12 7 12 43 3
    14 Blackpool 31 10 12 9 42 12
    15 Morecambe 31 12 6 13 42 -7
    16 Crawley 31 11 6 14 39 -11
    17 Yeovil 32 9 11 12 38 -7
    18 Crewe 32 8 12 12 36 -11
    19 Accrington 30 8 9 13 33 -10
    20 Notts County 32 9 6 17 33 -21
    21 Cheltenham 32 7 11 14 32 -10
    22 Hartlepool 32 7 11 14 32 -18
    23 Leyton Orient 32 8 5 19 29 -15
    24 Newport 32 5 11 16 26 -15
    Write for Vital Football
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    The Vital Football Members League

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

    Feb 25 2017 3:00PM : Carlisle United (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Feb 28 2017 7:45PM : Morecambe (H)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Mar 4 2017 3:00PM : Crewe Alexandra (H)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Mar 7 2017 7:45PM : Crawley Town (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Mar 11 2017 3:00PM : Colchester United (a)
    Sky Bet League Two
    Mar 14 2017 7:45PM : Grimsby Town (H)
    Sky Bet League Two

    Vital Members League Table

    Vital Football Comment