Vital Football

A blow or boost for youth development?

A blow or boost for youth development?

Has the youth of Pompey suffered another blow, or will this now take a step in the right direction again?

The biggest blow that the youth set-up of Pompey could have taken came a few years back when Paul Hart was promoted into the role of 'caretaker manager', eventually permanent manager as that meant his input into the development of the future of Pompey was lost.

A 1st team manager role is not one for Harty, and sadly from the second he stepped up we had lost him in the youth area for good...

In the summer of 2009 came the appointment of Paul Smalley.

This was 'meant' to herald a new era for Pompey as his background of working with, and helping the development, of youngsters was 'said' to be good.

Fast forward to the present day and The News yesterday reported 'Paul Smalley has left Pompey with immediate effect.

'The head of youth operations yesterday came to a mutual agreement with the Blues to depart the role he has occupied since July 2009.'

I have to say that I have had serious concerns about the future of player development at Fratton for a while now, and I fear that we are starting to take a path, and to be fair have been on this for a while now, that is heading us towards 'virtually' bringing an end to this area for the club?

The importance of having a youth set-up with Pompey cannot be stressed enough, it IS vital that we do this as our future may very well hinge on us doing this!

The production of our own 'produce', if you will, can save plenty of money not to mention earn us some as well - of course we do not want to be a 'selling club' but realistically if we can develop a young talent and then sell him for several million needs must, right?

This can then be put back into further development and the running of the club. In theory anyway!

It is said that we 'will now seek to recruit a replacement'.

We just have to hope that we do just that and when we do we bring in someone that can help get our youth development back on track.

Also we have to hope that this is an area that the club want to do want to work with again and it was simple not working out with Smalley and nothing to do with a lack of interest in this area anymore, so his departure will be beneficial. The club has been losing its way in this area - and virtually every area - in recent times after putting so much time, effort and money into building this up.

Please Pompey do not let the youth development of this club die off, if we do this then the consequences for this club could also be terminal...


  • Click here to make your prediction: Pompey v Millwall.

  • Click here to make your prediction: Brighton v Pompey.

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate


  • Frippy's Virtual Bookies - latest update and place your bets!

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Sunday December 19 2010
    Time: 9:47AM


    This was on the OS yesterday with quotes from Smalley and Lampitt
    19/12/2010 11:08:00
    don't think smalley was doing that great a job so don't really see it as a blow, and Cotterill commented at the beginning of the season the youth set-up needed a lot of work so sounds like it was a waste of money anyway, but how really knows
    19/12/2010 11:51:00
    We need a strong youth production line; they have to be given the chance to play in the first team young. How old were Rooney, Owen, and Rodwell etc when they were given their chance? I think I'm right but anyone this age would be exempt from the limit of 20 players.
    19/12/2010 12:11:00
    The Truth is Sc has made himself as popular as Herpes amongst the young players at the club. He never bothers to watch them play and has treated some like ****...Paul Smalley stood up to him and thats that. They hated him at Burnley as well...Hes done well with the first team so far but has put our youth development back ten years. When every other club can see the benefit of youngsters coming through, our steve keeps on swimming in his own bull****.
    19/12/2010 14:10:00
    I agree with you to a certain point landblue. In fact I am very pleased Ward has been playing and has played a role this season so far. I don't like the idea of moaning about lack of numbers and having some great young talent playing in the lower leagues when they can give us the numbers we need and maybe, who knows, some new fresh blood.
    Pompey Malta
    19/12/2010 17:15:00
    Uplandblue I think you have a lot of it right, I don't see there being any youth development at the moment. Youth development is expensive and the success rate is about 1:50. Pompey don't have the money and Cotterille isn't interested; I suspect - but don't have any evidence- Cot could have the same deal as Mr 10% Redknapp. Lol bit unlucky picking Portsmouth, don't see much in the way of player movement.
    19/12/2010 20:33:00
    a bloke i meet occasionally through work has a nephew at the club in the youth set up, and he says Smalley is an idiot who plays long ball all the time.
    plymouth graham
    19/12/2010 21:32:00
    a bloke i meet occasionally through work has a nephew at the club in the youth set up, and he says Smalley is an idiot who plays long ball all the time.
    plymouth graham
    19/12/2010 21:32:00
    Page 1/1
    1. 1

    Login to post a comment

    Best of International Football News


    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    No midfield addition...ahead of Rotherham anyway

    With Rose out for the season, on-loan Cardiff man O'Keefe for the next three months, a defensive midfielder is needed, right? They could arrive, but not ahead of Rotherham tomorrow.

    Blues' line up at Rotherham?

    The Pompey season continued with a draw against Scunthorpe. Well, that has been and gone so we move forward and go again against Rotherham in, obviously in League One, on Saturday.

    Vital Preview - League One - 20th January 2018

    The 2017-18 season continues with the latest round of games this weekend, 20th January.

    On this day in history...19th January

    A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 19th January.

    Portsmouth Archived Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    Editor email
    Editor email

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Rotherham v Pompey
    Suggested By: pompeyrug
    Pompey win13%
    Rotherham win50%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
    The Vital Football Members League
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    Vital Football Comment

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures

    Vital Members League Table

    Write for Vital Football