Vital Football

Pompey win - HMRC waive appeal

Pompey win - HMRC waive appeal

After hours of deliberating over his decision Mr Justice Mann has decided not to allow the HMRC plea to overturn the CVA.

The case however will not now go to the Court of Appeal tomorrow as the HMRC have decided against that course of action.

Mr Justice Mann said: "I propose to find in favour of the company administrators and dismiss the application of HMRC."

The judge said the proposed CVA would stand.

In his verdict Mann said 'I find that none of the five heads of attack by HMRC amount to unfair prejudice nor have they been materially affected.

'In my view, HMRC will not be worse off by the situation left by the CVA bearing in mind what the alternatives could be for the club.

'Those alternatives are liquidation, or expulsion from the Football League or worse, bearing in mind the loss of a lot of their assets.'

The judge said that without the Company Voluntary Agreement, there was no hope of keeping the club afloat. He went on: 'There is no worthwhile way of money coming into the club other than by the CVA.'

He said that in his opinion Balram Chainrai was the only possible new owner.

He said: 'Mr Chainrai was the owner of the club at the time of its demise and he is the only possible new owner now. There is no reason to suppose there is anyone else interested at all that would keep the club's status in the Championship.'

In a statement, HMRC said: 'HMRC is naturally disappointed not to have won this appeal and we can confirm that we do not intend to appeal.

'Our aim when pursuing debt of any kind is to achieve a fair outcome for the taxpayer and we will take this forward in the wider context of the football industry through separate and outstanding legal proceedings over the status of the so called "Football Creditors Rule.

'This is an important and complex judgment and until we have had the opportunity to study it in detail we can't comment further.'

After the verdict ewas announced Pompey's administrators immediately asked the court for £230,000 costs from the taxman.


PUP

Win FREE pizza with Vital Football!
Select your team and get 50% off if they score twice.
www.papajohns.co.uk/football



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:eastneydave
Date:Thursday August 5 2010
Time: 4:14PM

Best of Vital Network

Comments

0
I will try and get more news to you when it is available.
eastneydave
05/08/2010 16:16:00
0
Is that a chink of light at the end of the longest ever tunnel?
paultsmouth
05/08/2010 16:19:00
0
Let's hope that it is not the lights of an oncoming train, Paul. It's more likely to be Gaydamak looking for his money.
wellyit
05/08/2010 16:22:00
0
=)
pompey--pessimist
05/08/2010 16:23:00
0
The News are reporting that there will NOT be an appeal by HMRC.
NorfolknBlue
05/08/2010 16:25:00
0
How can they continue to appeal. Is it down to the judge to say enough is enough?
uktony
05/08/2010 16:25:00
0
HMRC WONT APPEAL =)
pompey--pessimist
05/08/2010 16:28:00
0
uktony - the judge cannot advise with appeals. it was upto HMRC to decide if they could argue any points of law. and i think they realised they couldnt. they will attach the fa in court in november i believe and they will go to town on them clearing up corruption in football... and fair play to them if they succeed. we should be one of the first football teams to learn from mistakes and be in order from now on!
pompey--pessimist
05/08/2010 16:30:00
0
Is this true - that there is not going to be an appeal? . . Can it really be so? Is the nightmare really over?
tracyc
05/08/2010 16:33:00
0
NO APPEAL - JUDGE MADE IT CLEAR!!
scott mc
05/08/2010 16:34:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

No Crawley return for Tubbs

Tubbs doesn't have a future at Pompey, he's on the transfer-list but offloading him could be difficult given his wages. These wouldn't be anywhere within Crawley's reach.

Pitfalls of Sheffield Wednesday loanee returning

As Catlin put it 'the gamble' of aiming sign Sheffield Wednesday loanee Lavery has to be one Pompey fans understand. It isn't as cut and dried as saying 'he's a free agent' sign him!

Lassie coming home...well sort of!

A-box-to-box player, capable of defensive duties, with ability to burst forward with intent to make things happen - Diarra is Pompey's man and wants an England return. I jest of course!

Will pair stay at Fratton?

It's been made (more than once) clear by Catlin Pompey want Davies & Hollands to stay. Both (also more than once) have said they want to this - deals have to be right for all concerned.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile
Chix
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

PO - Plymouth MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Allsop11%
Davies3%
Burgess19%
Barton53%
Stevens0%
Evans0%
Hollands1%
Doyle7%
Bennett0%
McNulty3%
Roberts0%
Sub - McGurk1%
Sub - Close1%
Sub - Chaplin1%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Northampton 46 29 12 5 99 36
P Oxford 46 24 14 8 86 43
P Bristol Rovers 46 26 7 13 85 31
4 Accrington 46 24 13 9 85 26
5 Plymouth 46 24 9 13 81 26
6 Portsmouth 46 21 15 10 78 31
7 Wimbledon 46 21 12 13 75 14
8 Leyton Orient 46 19 12 15 69 -1
9 Cambridge 46 18 14 14 68 11
10 Carlisle 46 17 16 13 67 5
11 Luton 46 19 9 18 66 2
12 Mansfield 46 17 13 16 64 8
13 Wycombe 46 17 13 16 64 1
14 Exeter 46 17 13 16 64 -2
15 Barnet 46 17 11 18 62 -1
16 Hartlepool 46 15 6 25 51 -23
17 Notts County 46 14 9 23 51 -29
18 Stevenage 46 11 15 20 48 -15
19 Yeovil 46 11 15 20 48 -16
20 Crawley 46 13 8 25 47 -33
21 Morecambe 46 12 10 24 46 -22
22 Newport 46 10 13 23 43 -21
R Dag & Red 46 8 10 28 34 -35
R York 46 7 13 26 34 -36
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.pompeyrug76
2.storagematt30
3.FrattonBlue28
4.Copnor4324
5.mslorna4820
6.Emsworthianblue12
7.eastneydave12
8.Ronald Wilson7
9.Jimsmithswig7
10.Pompeyboosie7