Vital Football

Day one in the High Court...

Day one in the High Court...

Day one is done and dusted, we go onto day two today as we move closer to finding out what the future holds for Pompey.

Whilst I would not get 'carried away', from my reading into things - and I am not being unduly optimistic, I think - I would say we hold a 'slight' advantage as it stands...

It 'seems', and from some of the texts that I have had and lines I have read on t'internet, as if the judge has been 'less than impressed' at times with HMRC's case, apparently he has even questioned the basis of their case against Pompey as it does not exactly seem, whilst what has happened has 'arguably' not been right, they have anything new to challenge things as they stand in football?

The main issue clearly centres around how much money HMRC feels they 'should' be entitled to in relation to what they 'would' get.

They feel, and probably rightly so in all honesty, that it is 'unfair' that secured football creditors will get back the full whack on what they are owed, whereas the taxman and other unsecured creditors have to settle for a percentage as agreed on a CVA - it should really be one rule for all and not some. As I say, this is unfair and football creditors should not be entitled to any preferential treatment but those are 'the rules' so what can they do?

Obviously all rules are eventually challenged, and inevitably these rules eventually change, although will this be the time...

The actual amount owed is also the seriously challenged issue with Pompey accused of avoiding millions in taxes by operating a 'tax sham', due to the 'image rights' issue.

This has not, as far as I am aware, been 'illegal' - although it may now be? - basically, my understanding of 'image rights' was that it is a means of topping up a players wages, in essence to almost make them paid 'tax free', with this amount gained topping up the shortfall from their basic wages lost in tax.

Again though this is not an issue that has been trialled, and successfully won, in the past. Lets make this perfectly clear, Portsmouth Football Club IS NOT the only club doing this...

This appeal is against the CVA agreement, where HMRC - like the other non-secured creditors - would get 20p in the £, although at this point in time, again not wishing to 'raise hopes' too much or anything like that, the case being brought before the judge, including the introduction of 'new evidence' does not seem to be arguing this specific point very well apart from highlighting how 'unfair' some things are!

Lots of things are unfair in this world, although simply being unfair is not always enough for a challenge to be successful, and successfully doing this would almost certainly accelerate our path to oblivion - with this thought in mind, and the consequences that this would mean for Portsmouth Football Club and its hundreds of thousands of followers we 'may well' get lucky...

As said, the new evidence and the case being presented so far 'seems' to be irritating the judge somewhat, and irritating a judge is the last thing that HMRC would want to do, although it is the best thing for us for them to be doing this!

With the court reconvening today, again at 10.30am, lets hope the slim - it seems - half time lead we 'seem' to have can be carried through to full time with the judge, when he makes his ruling, bringing the hammer down in our favour tomorrow...

PLAY UP POMPEY!

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Trust



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:pompeyrug
Date:Wednesday August 4 2010
Time: 8:27AM

Comments

0
I find it incredible that HMRC don't have more than they have put on the table so far. Maybe they will bring it out of the bag today?
Gandor1
04/08/2010 08:44:00
0
play up pompey ! come on u blues......
pompeyhussler
04/08/2010 09:00:00
0
Its all a farce...Gaydamak and Sons sit on a verysizable stack of rubles, whilst their Patsy Peter Storrie will never work in football again, and the other pretens owners- i firmly think that they were all Noddy companies invented by gaydamak as an asset stripping vehicle-are happy onthier 6 months earnings...the whole sorry story is a sham...if it had been any other club i would demand that they be liquididated and put in the conferance. WHo would suffer though..you and me,but especially those who attend home and away( i am not one of those due to miles and money) rany over...someone prosecute Gaydamak...for something..any thing
plymouth graham
04/08/2010 09:04:00
0
These are scary times, I have my fingers crossed, I hope that we make it through..........
NZ_Portsmuff
04/08/2010 09:46:00
0
That's it Graham, rage against the machine. I'm not sure about the front company asset stripping thing is anything but fans conspiracy theories. What upsets me is that the PL has changed it's rules "to prevent another Pompey" when Scudamore and his people new about it all along; the hypocrisy is stunning. We need to win this away game so let's hope we get the win and our Barrister plays a blinder and walks away with the points and man of the match award. Cringey vernacular.
russellm
04/08/2010 10:21:00
0
If the object of the HMRC exercise is to challenge the 'players first, etc' payments why have they singled us out? Why haven't they taken the PL and FL to court and argued the case? After all, it's a 'football' ruling that their own should be paid first not a Pompey decision.
PFCblue
04/08/2010 10:47:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Lewis Tips Joshua to Win

Vital F1 - Blog: Sochi Preview

Recent Portsmouth Articles

EFL Grounds Team Winners 2016/17

The Football League have this afternoon announced the divisional winners and runners up in this...

On this day in history...26th April

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 26th April.

Will Irish eyes be smiling?

Pompey will hope Irish eyes can indeed be smiling for former Aston Villa left back Enda Stevens with a call up to the Republic of Ireland squad coming as a Blues player.

On this day in history...25th April

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 25th April.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Cambridge MotM
Suggested By:
Forde5%
Evans0%
Whatmough17%
Clarke1%
Stevens5%
Opoku Aborah63%
Doyle1%
Baker0%
Naismith2%
Bennett5%
Kabamba0%
Sub-Chaplin0%
Sub-Lowe0%
Sub-Roberts1%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
P Doncaster 44 25 10 9 85 33
P Plymouth 44 25 8 11 83 24
P Portsmouth 44 24 9 11 81 33
4 Luton 44 18 17 9 71 22
5 Exeter 44 20 8 16 68 18
6 Blackpool 44 17 16 11 67 22
7 Stevenage 44 20 6 18 66 7
8 Mansfield 44 17 14 13 65 5
9 Wycombe 44 18 11 15 65 4
10 Carlisle 44 16 17 11 65 -1
11 Cambridge 44 18 9 17 63 7
12 Colchester 44 17 12 15 63 6
13 Accrington 44 16 14 14 62 3
14 Grimsby 44 17 10 17 61 -2
15 Barnet 44 13 15 16 54 -6
16 Notts County 44 15 8 21 53 -22
17 Crewe 44 13 13 18 52 -11
18 Morecambe 44 14 9 21 51 -18
19 Crawley 44 13 11 20 50 -16
20 Yeovil 44 11 16 17 49 -13
21 Cheltenham 44 11 14 19 47 -16
22 Newport 44 11 12 21 45 -22
23 Hartlepool 44 10 13 21 43 -21
R Leyton Orient 44 10 6 28 36 -36
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Apr 29 2017 3:00PM : Mansfield Town (a)
Sky Bet League Two
May 6 2017 5:30PM : Cheltenham Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.pompeyrug89
2.PompeyFrippy39
3.storagematt33
4.eastneydave30
5.Copnor4323
6.FrattonBlue18
7.stubbsy00718
8.uspompeyfan16
9.pompeyweller11
10.Jimsmithswig10
Write for Vital Football