Vital Football

No reserve football this season

No reserve football this season

Pompey have opted against taking a place in the Totesport.com combination league central division this season, and as such will not play reserve team football against the likes of Crawley, Aldershot, Leyton Orient, Brentford, Brighton, Palace and Gillingham...

The reserve team - as has happened in the past, to our cost - has been 'scrapped' for the season ahead with the club preferring to loan out youngsters instead of limiting them to reserve team football.

Maybe I am old fashioned but there is something about having a 'reserve team' that just seems a part of football - then again football is ever changing, sometimes for the better although sadly, for me in many ways, for the worse...

So, I know that I will miss not having a reserve team around - that said with the way our squad is looking would we actually have enough players to put out a reserve side anyway?

With the amount of players that have been released and sold, or will be sold, the 1st team numbers have/will dropped again this summer, as they have drastically over the past 18-months or so, so what would have been reserve players are now actually part of the 1st team squad, and the academy side could not have been expected to fulfil their commitments and the ressies too could they!

You 'rarely' see 1st team players in the reserves these days anyway, those that are do so merely to bridge that step-up gap, work on their fitness or do this as they are not in the 1st team picture - with the ability to arrange 'behind closed doors' friendlies, these can be used for fitness purposes.

As said I am a fan of reserve football but in all honesty you cannot beat 1st team football can you!

So, by sending those that have moved up from the academy, are on the fringes of the 1st team but are not quite ready yet for this here out on loan 'should' in theory only benefit them - the drawback is these players will become accustomed to 1st team football and in the modern era of patience not really being a virtue how long will players hand around at Fratton after these loan spells before they decide they have had enough and will look to move on?

Also, not everyone can be involved in the 1st team, and we cannot literally carry a skeleton squad (if possible) of 17, we would need a good 20, at least, around the club all the time to cover for injuries and suspensions - this will, of course, leave a surplus of at least 3 players, maybe more, each week that are getting no 1st team or reserve team football at all, so in terms of the financial thinking what are they actually doing, bar training, to earn their money?

That said I would hope that whatever squad we do end up this season will be utilised to its full, so it will not be a case of favourites play every week, so what happens in games and in training does contribute to who is involved as well, and this will be shaken up accordingly...

The News says that the club say this is not driven purely by a 'financial decision', this would have played a part in it of course, but with all due respect to those that the ressies would come up against perhaps this is the right call to make - and to be fair many other clubs are also taking this step too.

All in all though I do not think that we would have, in all honesty, enough players to be able to maintain a 1st team and reserve team anyway.

Hopefully this does remain only a temporary 'short-term' measure though and as we get ourselves back on our feet again, in spite of the benefits to be gained from sending players out on loan for regular 1st team football as opposed to 2nd string outings, this will be an area that returns down the line as I do think in the 'long-term' you do need to have a bridge gap between the academy and 1st team level, and that is also what the reserve team acts as...

PLAY UP POMPEY!

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

For more information about the Vital England predictions league game - click here.

For more information about the Vital England fantasy football game - click here.

Trust

Win FREE pizza with Vital Football!
Select your team and get 50% off if they score twice.
www.papajohns.co.uk/football



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:pompeyrug
Date:Wednesday July 7 2010
Time: 1:10PM

Comments

0
I don't care how they dress this up it's a financial decision, Pompey will not have a sufficient squad size to run a 1st and reserve team. Top clubs all have string reserve teams as they believe in strength in depth and by using the reserve team they can get players prep'd fro the first team strategy and start to blend their youth team into first team atmosphere. With all due respect Stoke and QPR are not big teams and both are run on extremely tight budgets. The other team mentioned in the News article as qouted by SC was spurs but has openly said he believes youth development is not particularly cost effective- well spurs have a very large and well funded youth policy so he can afford to let an over size squad go on loan. Also well Mr 10% Harry. Lumpitt and Cotterille need to be a bit truthfull now i m h o if they continue they will start to lose a bit of credibility.
russellm
07/07/2010 15:24:00
0
I also think it will encourage complacency; why put the effort in if there is no possibility of being replaced? :-) whinge over
russellm
07/07/2010 15:48:00
0
what we have to remember is the chances are we will have, what 25 players MAX this season - and that includes, arguably half of that number being academy graduates that are not 'really' ready for 1st team football, others that are will be in the 1st team squad...
after wedding out the players that are 'too good for the ressies' but 'not good enough, or prepared enough for the 1st team here' yet, the obvious step is to loan them out - say we have half a dozen of them i reckon we will be left with a 1st team squad of around 19-20 players for cotterill to select from this season.
17 will be involved for each game, that leaves 2-3 that will train but nothing else, altho i WOULD think that all 19-20 players WILL play a part this season.
so, in all reality could we really 'risk' putting 11 of these players out in the ressies every other week, if not would we 'really' have enough players to do this...
as said in the 'short-term' i think this is ok, but it MUST only be a short-term thing as down the line we will need the ressies to be the bridge gap from the academy to the 1st team, for a year or so before these kids are even ready to think of getting into another clubs 1st team on loan, let alone ours.
the worry is this is a worrying slope, which may become a slippery one to the whole set-up of this club crumbling - it is ok doing away with the ressies for a year or so, but any longer and we will do away with the academy set-up next and THAT is vital to our future!
pompeyrug
07/07/2010 16:37:00
0
1968...we have been here before...Pat Wright looking after Waterlooville, then the FA put paid to it. 1. this is a financial situation based decision without a doubt, however, 2. Its one I agree with at the moment. We are not going to be obvious contenders to get promotion and possibly look to be set to replace the red zebra's in Lg1..if we are to leave the championship at all, so we need to sort out the finances. sadly I feel the club is now effectively crippled with debt and it looks very unlikely that we will ever return to the heights we had recently known. 3. I do not care, as long as there is a Pompey. 4. I think SC will do a good job given time.
plymouth graham
08/07/2010 17:31:00
0
Short term gain, Long term disaster.
The Rabbi
09/07/2010 05:09:00
0
From Pompey's point of view I'm not that concerned, I don't even know if we'll have enough players to field a reserve side. But its a great shame for Havant & W'ville, who rent their ground to Pompey for their reserve fixtures. But its a pragmatic financial decision for Pompey and probably makes sense. We're not the only club to make this decision either.
tracyc
09/07/2010 16:58:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

On this day in history...3rd May

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 3rd May.

Who Will Portsmouth Face In 2016/17 (3/5/16)

With less than a handful of games remaining in the 2015/16 campaign, some promotions and relegations in the football pyramid are already known.

April MotM Nomination - Cook (Portsmouth)

The April nominations for the Sky Bet League 2 Manager of the Month Award are in.

Match highlights - Hartlepool 0-2 Pompey

The slim chances of a top 3 finish ended, despite a win at Hartlepool. Wins for Accrington, Oxford and Bristol Rovers meant Pompey cannot finish higher than our current 5th place.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile
Chix
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Hartlepool MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Murphy55%
Stevens0%
Burgess9%
Barton0%
Freeman0%
Doyle0%
Hollands0%
Naismith19%
Roberts9%
Evans0%
Smith4%
Sub - McGurk0%
Sub - Chaplin4%
Sub - Whatmough0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Northampton 45 28 12 5 96 35
2 Accrington 45 24 12 9 84 26
3 Oxford 45 23 14 8 83 40
4 Bristol Rovers 45 25 7 13 82 30
5 Portsmouth 45 21 15 9 78 32
6 Plymouth 45 23 9 13 78 21
7 Wimbledon 45 20 12 13 72 13
8 Cambridge 45 18 13 14 67 11
9 Leyton Orient 45 18 12 15 66 -2
10 Wycombe 45 17 13 15 64 4
11 Exeter 45 17 13 15 64 1
12 Carlisle 45 16 16 13 64 0
13 Mansfield 45 17 12 16 63 8
14 Luton 45 18 9 18 63 -1
15 Barnet 45 16 11 18 59 -4
16 Hartlepool 45 15 6 24 51 -18
17 Notts County 45 14 9 22 51 -24
18 Yeovil 45 11 15 19 48 -15
19 Stevenage 45 11 14 20 47 -15
20 Crawley 45 13 8 24 47 -30
21 Morecambe 45 12 9 24 45 -22
22 Newport 45 10 13 22 43 -20
R Dag & Red 45 8 10 27 34 -34
R York 45 7 12 26 33 -36
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

May 7 2016 3:00PM : Northampton Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.FrattonBlue2
2.eastneydave2
3.Copnor432
4.mslorna481
5.Emsworthianblue1