Vital Football

The penalty king should be...

The penalty king should be...

'Jamie O'Hara should be the Pompey penalty taker', not my vote, yours - although these findings from pompeyrug's poll are thoughts that I would not be against, but would not necessarily have him as my number one spot kick taker to be honest...

Yep, I do not think that O'Hara would be a bad penalty taker - far from it but someone that seems to have nerves, and balls, of steel is ideal for penalties, so I guess that makes The Herminator ideal, right?

He showed in Asia a couple of years back that he can take them and his strike against Burnley was that of a striker!

Even so, for me, I think I would go for Younes everyday of the week as I think if he just stood up and lashed the ball, as he often does with free kicks, he would not go far wrong.

Boateng has the confidence but I just do not think that he has the finishing ability to be a regular penalty taker, I would not be overly confident that he would score, I was not against Stoke and he missed, nor was I against Manyoo and he did - Dindane, well, enough said...

All in all I cannot really think of many alternatives in the current set-up though!

  • What the poll asked - Who would YOU want to see taking our penalties?

  • How you voted - O'Hara 30%, Hreidarsson 22%, Boateng 20%, Kaboul 18%, Someone else 8%, Dindane 2%

    Before we move on what are your thoughts on what the last poll concluded? You know what to do, thoughts below please guys...


    Bookmark and Share

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Friday December 11 2009
    Time: 8:00AM


    Still think Kaboul is the man, all the best penalties go at 90 mph, he wants to take free-kicks, so why not pens?
    11/12/2009 07:39:00
    Younes got my vote, but I still think any professional footy player should be able to take a penalty FFS !! Particularly a striker - anyway please practice them regularly. Even that scummer Matt Le Cissier said it best "a penalty was the best opportunity I ever had to score". Come on lads step up to the spot and show us you've got a pair.
    11/12/2009 12:33:00
    I missed this one, but I would have voted for Hermann. Even since he rifled that one against Liverpool in the Asia Trophy, I've said he should be taking our spot kicks. Although if you could pick any Pompey player past or present to take a penalty, who would it be? I'd be torn between Macca and Unsworth. Yak, although never missed, never had me convinced.
    11/12/2009 14:36:00
    I voted for O'Hara, but yes both Kaboul and Hermann are good candidates. However, I still think Boateng will be taking them. I just hope that he is spending some time on how to take them in training!
    Pompey Malta
    11/12/2009 14:43:00
    I voted for Herman as well, and it was because I remembered how well he took his penalty in the Asia cup. Herman loves scoring goals! As for past or present penalty taker - Kevin 'Dead Eye' Dillon everytime.
    11/12/2009 17:53:00
    i think any player should be able to take them, but KPB showed a bit of courage to step up after his previous miss so i wouldnt complain if it was him. remember a loy of YK's free kicks are erm how shall i put this..... not quite of the standard we would like them to be
    11/12/2009 19:09:00
    I missed this vote unfortunately, but had I been voting it would probably have been younes, he can certainy get that ball moving at a real clip, I guess they make these decision with the form of the training ground so maybe KPB is the right man for the job!
    11/12/2009 22:02:00
    i take it no-one remembers o'haras PK miss in the carling cup?
    12/12/2009 00:06:00
    Page 1/1
    1. 1

    Login to post a comment

    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    Pompey Predictions League - updates #33 & #34

    The Pompey Predictions League is part of this site now isn't it. Would it be the same without? This continued with defeats against Fleetwood and Blackpool.

    Follow Oldham v Pompey On Twitter - 17-03-18

    Pompey go to Boundary Park as the visitors to Oldham today, this will be a 3pm kick-off.

    Seven month consultation yields result

    There was much speculation about what would happen, what the final outcome could bring and how happy - or disappointed - this was going to leave us. The new Pompey club crest is known.

    Oldham - 17th March - Boundary Park

    The recent form at Fratton Park has been terrible. Then again it's hardly stunning away from the South Coast, but we'll hope to put Oldham under pressure and collect a much-needed win.

    Portsmouth Archived Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    Editor email
    Editor email

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Oldham v Pompey
    Suggested By: pompeyrug
    Pompey win12%
    Oldham win73%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
    Write for Vital Football
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    The Vital Football Members League

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures

    Vital Members League Table

    10.Dorking Pompey2
    Vital Football Comment