Vital Football

Sunday Toast Season 3 # 15 - replay games?

Sunday Toast Season 3 # 15 - replay games?

No game yet this weekend which gives me little to talk about but I have no doubt I will think of something in your Sunday Toast.

Just a quick note to apologise to users who may have experienced some problems accessing Vital Football recently. This is not the fault of Vital and all steps are being taken to ensure you receive the service you require and deserve.

Team of the Decade

Last week we announced the plan to name the team of the noughties decade at the end of the year. Nominations are trickling in and we will launch a thread to bring in more shortly.

Meanwhile as a taster we start a new series looking back at the team of the previous for decades starting with the 1960s.

1960's team

1. John Milkins
2. Roy Pack
3. George Ley
4. Brian Lewis
5. Jimmy Dickinson
6. Harry Harris
7. Tony Barton
8. Johnny Gordon
9. Ron Saunders
10. Albert McCann
11. Nicky Jennings

The team of my youth but still difficult to select. There were some 100% definite selections - John Milkins, Ron Saunders and Nicky Jennings and then there was the inspiration of the likes of Harry Harris and Johnny Gordon plus the skill of Brian Lewis and Albie McCann.

All in all a good side, I think, led of course by the great man himself Gentleman Jimmy Dickinson who make the team from any decade and if I went back to the 40's and 50's he would be in both those teams too. Remember Jim played 764 league games for Pompey and won forty eight England caps and was never booked!

Two of the team went on to make their name in management (Barton and Saunders) combining to take Aston Villa to win the European Cup - Barton replacing Saunders four months before Bayern Munich were beaten by a Peter Withe goal in Rotterdam in 1982.

Roy Pack and George Ley were a good pair of full backs and fought off the competition from long serving Alex Wilson, Phil Gunter and Roy Lunniss. Others unlucky not to make the final XI were pacy winger John McClelland, local boy Ray Hiron who scored over 100 goals for Pompey and the elegant Ray Pointer. Others were to make it into the 70's team which we will unveil next week.


Some talk about the luck of the Irish but it certainly ran out last week. Many of the boys in green have been signing up to the Toast campaign for video officials and goal judges and because of this we have decided to take some definitive action and write on behalf of football to FIFA!!

Memo to FIFA

Well what a fine mess you have got yourself into now.

We wrote to you last year suggesting that you implement our recommendation of five officials and television replays immediately but alas you took no action and now the hand of god has intervened.

The incident at the Stade de France last Wednesday was the latest of many such incidents which have now thrown the game into disrepute. We now have accusations of cheating, threats to boycott shaving products and the risk of international confrontations all because FIFA will not spend a tiny percentage of their huge resources on putting into action what the plan the whole world knows is required.

Quite how FIFA dig themselves out of this hole is of course your problem but one thing is for certain the match cannot be replayed as those ignorant of the game implore. The laws of the game do not allow it and if one were to be re-arranged then every club and country in the world would be queuing at your door with a list of games for your consideration.

It is of course more than a matter of financially reimbursing the FOI for the lost of revenue a trip to South Africa for the World Cup Finals would have earned but is has also robbed the Irish players a one off chance to play in such a great tournament.

The blame lies firmly at you door and you must act NOW to save the credibility of our great game.

P.S. If however you do decide to replay games I would make a request for the game between Arsenal and Portsmouth at Highbury on Saturday 13th September 2003. The reason was the dive made by Robert Pires that earned the home side a penalty which was converted by Thierry Henry (yes the very same!!) but only at the second attempt. The consequence of decision was that Arsenal would go the entire season undefeated and they should have lost that game.

Algeria make World Cup

It was good to see that Algeria have qualified for the World Cup Finals in South Africa next year. They squeezed past World Cup under achievers Egypt in a Khartoum play-off. Egypt have won the African Cup of Nations six times but only qualified for one World Cup Finals since the war. Algeria's qualification will give us some more interest in the competition from the point of watching our players.

Sounds as though Billy Belhadj had his usual 'mixed' game. Booked in the first minute but making a couple of good sorties forward and making one decisive defensive tackle. Yebda dabba doo also played and created opportunities which sadly were missed.

For anyone who missed it the final place in the Finals was taken by Uruguay who edged out Costa Rica 2-1 on aggregate. The draw for the finals will be made on 4th December in Cape Town. Pompey's current players who could be involved are David James, Nadir Belhadj, Hassan Yebda, Aruna Dindane, Kevin Prince Boateng (for Ghana), Kanu, John Utaka, Angelos Basinas, Aaron Mokoena and maybe even Younes Kaboul for France. Of course the number of ex Pompey players will run into dozens!!

There are many fans who believe that Marc Wilson should now be in the Ireland squad. Well I think that the Irish World Cup exit could be a blessing in disguise as they will now play a series of meaningless friendlies against countries that have qualified. That will mean that manager Giovanni Trapattoni will have an opportunity to blood new players and surely Marc will fall into that group.

Good luck to him he has put in the effort and now deserves his chance.

Jock job

George Burley fell on his sword last week after Scotland's woeful performance in Cardiff. Well I was reading the Daily Record on the train the other night (the things I do for research!) and it contained and eight page special on who does not want the job.

It is a poisoned chalice no doubt but one after one possible candidate has come out and said 'no thanks'.

The problem with Scottish football is not the quality of their managers but the fact that although they can produce a good crop of youngsters they are unable to convert them into a strong national side. Is it down to the fact that there are in essence only two teams north of the border or does the problem lie elsewhere?

Certainly I can remember back in the sixties they produced the like of Denis Law, Billy Bremner, Jim Baxter etc. etc. As a team they were often more than a match for their English counterparts and remember Celtic were the first British club to win the European Cup in 1967. Yet as a country they have got past the first phase of the world cup final despite qualifying eight times.

Pompey are a club that have had a lot of Scottish players over the years particularly in the early doing deal with a large number of clubs. The only player to hail from north of the border now is Glasgow born Richard Hughes.

So where does Scottish football go from here?

Germany calling

Last week we told you that Toast had a reporter in Hanover at the time of the Robert Enke suicide. Tina has now returned to Pompey and tells me that they were reading Toast in Germany!! She has bought me back the local papers covering the event and I will give you some extracts in the weeks ahead - Tina will have to translate them for me first! One thing that did hit Tina was the fact that in all the papers and media coverage there was not one bad word mentioned about Enke.

The most upsetting part of the trip for Tina was travelling from Hamburg to Hanover on the same day the two Bundesliga sides were playing each other. Trains, stations, streets were all full of riot police in their full gear including helmets, shields, tasers and guns. Not a day she would like to repeat and some think we have crowd problems in Britain!

Finally good luck to Sam Allardyce who is to undergo minor heart surgery in the next few days.


A couple of new names on the list this week with two players celebrating their first birthdays at the club.

22nd November
Yakubu Aiyegbeni is 27 - has been nominated for the team of the noughties. Russell Hoult is 37 and still playing at Darlington on loan. I calculate that that is his eighth loan club.
23rd November
Anthony Fenton is 30 and is working as a recruitment consultant.
24th November
Gavin Maguire is 42 Clive Whitehead is 54.
25th November
Aaron Mokoena the Axe is 29.
26th November
Aruna Dindane is 29. David Lee is 40. Peter Denyer is 52. John Ruggiero is 55.
27th November
Matthew Taylor is 28 and has also been nominated for the team of the noughties. Mark Kelly is 43. Rodney Henwood is 78.
28th November
Trevor Senior is 48. Mick Channon is 61. Reg Flewin born in 1920 and passed away in 2008. Would in my opinion be nominated in the team for any decade. Pompey born and captained his team to win the championship twice!


Bookmark and Share

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Sunday November 22 2009
Time: 5:00AM


Morning toasters.... I've been sat here for a few minutes trying to build a case for Ray Hirons inclusion into the the team of the 60's but can't quite manage to convince myself that he should replace Johnny Gordon or Ron Saunders.. but I might work on Ray Pointers inclusion .. trouble is I have to bow to Daves superior knowledge of the decade ... but bring on the 70's !!.

As for replay games I've heard that Vital Germany have requested that FIFA look at a certain World Cup final, Spurs fans have requested they examine Perdro Mendes' goal v Manchester United and finally Vital Man Utd have requested a repla of everygame they have lost in the past five years ..

Finally.. A left side nomination for the team of the noughties... Gianluca Festa .. only 27 games but (for me and many others) one of the key reasons we got promoted and surely one of the most deserved goals ever in the history of PFC..
22/11/2009 08:19:00
morning guys, just a quick word as i have to head off for stoke - fantastic read as ever tho toast team, i have so much to say but not time to do so, but i would say they might want to look at the game - also against arsenal - that cost us a uefa cup place with a disallowed goal...
i will get some noughties with you asap. right, that will have to be all...
22/11/2009 08:39:00
Has anyone thought that if officials were able to act on the Henry hand ball at the time it happened, he would have been sent off for it is the same as diving for a penalty. The ref should have a red or green light that approves or warns of bad or good decisions.
22/11/2009 10:57:00
That hand ball brings to mind the really really daft handball that Papa gave us last year. Can't remember who we were playing at the time, was it Arsenal? I cannot see that the France/Ireland game could possily be replayed, but I do feel sorry for Ireland. Cannot possibly comment on the team of the decade, although some of the names are familiar. Is anyone going to the Eastney Tavern for the match? Good Toast Dave, as usual.
22/11/2009 12:40:00
All you need is the 4th official with a TV monitor. My idea is that each manager has a limited number of calls per match - 2 perhaps, where he can ask the 4th official to review and make an instant decision, either tell the ref his decision was wrong, or uphold it. I can't see what the problem is with this. They do similar things in tennis and rugby. So is the Eastney Tavern the place to be when away games are on Sky then?
22/11/2009 19:48:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News


Recent Portsmouth Articles

Worthy of a new deal?

So, Danny Rose, as we know, isn't going to play again this season. As things stand this would mean he'll not pull on a Pompey shirt again as his contract expires in the summer.

Sickening Rotherham winner

Losing on Saturday was bad enough, the fact this was an added time winner more so. The cherry on the cake was the fact Rotherham's goal came from ex-Pompey full back Joe Mattock.

On this day in history...22nd January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd January.

On this day in history...21st January

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st January.

Portsmouth Archived Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Should Danny Rose get a new deal?
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Yes, get it done ASAP72%
Yes, once he's proven his fitness14%
No, regardless of his injury14%
I'll sit on the fence - KJ knows best0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

Write for Vital Football