Vital Football

They are Scottish - keep it that way!

They are Scottish - keep it that way!

I do not know if I missed something, with this 'something' being the trigger for this, but all of a sudden the topic on plenty of premier league managers minds again is that of 'Celtic and Rangers joining the premier league.'

This is something that has rumbled on for several years, but during this international break - and perhaps it is this international break that sees this topic rise again as people cannot think of anything else to talk about? - it has returned.

It appears that Villa manager Martin O'Neill is 'in favour' of this, as is Everton's David Moyes and then we have Spurs manager Harry Redknapp, who has to have a say about everything as he knows everything, also seemingly happy to see them join the English game?

My question is why would they want this?

Why should we allow the 'Scottish giants' into the premier league?

They are Scottish so they should stay in the Scottish premier league - if they, and the 'super powers' in the English, or even European game, want this then why do they nod sod off and create this 'super league' that is also often spoken about, is the 'almighty' champions league not enough...

I just cannot get my head round the thought as to why we should, let alone would, let these Scottish clubs join the premier league? Well, join the English league at any level - it is not our fault that the Scottish game is so poor, football and financially wise - that said maybe you 'could' argue that all the money in the English game is ruining the 'British' game?

I know we have a few Welsh sides playing in the English game, and quite why this is I honestly could not say - but this has been the way I have always known it, and for God knows how long, again why it is I do not know, anyone?

Ok, lets just say Celtic and Rangers 'were' allowed to join the English league WHY should they be allowed to jump straight into the premier league?

The dream - although in all honesty it is not always as 'wonderful' as you hope once you get there, not that I am saying I want out mind - for all championship, league one, league two and non-league clubs is to make it into the 'promised land' that is the premier league.

So, how is it 'fair' - not that fair counts for much these days - that Celtic and Rangers 'could' be able to bypass the pyramid system and leap straight into the top flight?

I would hope that this does not happen anyway, but if it did then make them start at the bottom like the rest do and work their way up to the top!

Am I the only one against the idea of Celtic and Rangers joining the premier league - and am I also the only one who cannot under stand why the likes of O'Neill, Moyes and Redknapp would not be against it?

As always share your thoughts below...

PLAY UP POMPEY!


Bookmark and Share


Join the Vital Pompey Debate



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:pompeyrug
Date:Thursday November 12 2009
Time: 11:43AM

Comments

0
I would prefer we got rid of the welsh sides, and then had an competition between english welsh and scottish as part of the Preseason for the top 4 from each? Would keep them all happy and get the Non English Teams out of the English League... Its farcical. As portsmouth does not have Country all round it, thanks to the coast line, maybe we could opt to join the french league? After all its nearer to us than Scotland? And no, i am joking i dont really want it lol
Midge
12/11/2009 12:18:00
0
There's no way either team would be anywhere near the standard required to challenge the mythical 'Top Four', and would be mid-table fodder at best. This is ENTIRELY about money. And once you start talking about integrating them into our Leagues, what about relegation? Once they get dropped a division they'd be begging the SPL to take them back. What about the Cups? Either Glasgow team versus the likes of Millwall is not a very savoury prospect. Keep them out.
Tantona
12/11/2009 12:18:00
0
agreed and i'm pretty sure the celtic and rangers supports will agree just imagine having to travel all the way down to England let alone the south coast for a league game ffs.... its ridculous, greed and just not realistic for the fans!!
pompeym@
12/11/2009 12:35:00
0
Not for them joining. A small step away from a european league. may as well invite Real Madrid & Barca than Rangers & Celtic.
storagematt
12/11/2009 12:36:00
0
Who cares
russellm
12/11/2009 12:56:00
0
doesn't matter guys the vote was this morning and it got turned down AGAIN lol
pompeym@
12/11/2009 13:21:00
0
The proposal is being discussed by the PL today. It means forming a 2 division PL with Celtic & Rangers and 'some' Championship teams. There will be no promotion or relegation into or out of lower leagues - a closed shop. Amazingly the proposer is the Bolton Chairman Phil Gartside, whereas most lower PL teams are against it.
NorfolknBlue
12/11/2009 13:21:00
0
The worrying thing for us is the criteria being talked about for teams to enter from the Championship (only should the worst come to the worst of course), such things as grounds, facilities, academies, finances etc etc. PUP
NorfolknBlue
12/11/2009 13:27:00
0
All over - the proposal has been rejected. BBC R5L 13.30.
NorfolknBlue
12/11/2009 13:38:00
0
stupid idea and if it did happen they should start in league 1 and work there way up to the premier league.
PompeyFcMad
12/11/2009 14:01:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Wigan in for Paul Cook

Wigan have made an approach for Paul Cook but can Pompey keep their prized asset?....

On this day in history...27th May

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 27th May.

Ben Close signs new deal

Ben Close signs a new one year deal with a one year option as Pompey continue the job of gathering a squad ...

Some will 'fulfil their career elsewhere'

Names weren't mentioned but Main is seen as having 'no Fratton future' as Cook prepares, if he hasn't already, to inform people they may need to 'fulfil their career elsewhere'.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Can Pompey kick on in League One?
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Yes, we'll win it13%
We'll be runners up0%
Top-six30%
Top-10 (7th-10th)26%
Midtable11%
Bottom half11%
No, we'll be relegated9%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Portsmouth 46 26 9 11 87 39
P Plymouth 46 26 9 11 87 25
P Doncaster 46 25 10 11 85 30
4 Luton 46 20 17 9 77 27
5 Exeter 46 21 8 17 71 19
6 Carlisle 46 18 17 11 71 1
7 Blackpool 46 18 16 12 70 23
8 Colchester 46 19 12 15 69 10
9 Wycombe 46 19 12 15 69 5
10 Stevenage 46 20 7 19 67 4
11 Cambridge 46 19 9 18 66 8
12 Mansfield 46 17 15 14 66 4
13 Accrington 46 17 14 15 65 3
14 Grimsby 46 17 11 18 62 -4
15 Barnet 46 14 15 17 57 -7
16 Notts County 46 16 8 22 56 -22
17 Crewe 46 14 13 19 55 -9
18 Morecambe 46 14 10 22 52 -20
19 Crawley 46 13 12 21 51 -18
20 Yeovil 46 11 17 18 50 -15
21 Cheltenham 46 12 14 20 50 -20
22 Newport 46 12 12 22 48 -22
R Hartlepool 46 11 13 22 46 -21
R Leyton Orient 46 10 6 30 36 -40
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.pompeyrug198
2.PompeyFrippy55
3.storagematt42
4.pompeyweller28
5.Copnor4325
6.eastneydave22
7.stubbsy00715
8.Jimsmithswig10
9.FrattonBlue9
10.uspompeyfan4
Vital Football Comment