Choose your club

Vital Mobile

Vital Shop

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Brown backs the diamond, do you?

We have tried an orthodox 4-4-2, albeit not very often, what is sometimes 'said' to be a 4-3-3 but is more often than not a 4-5-1 in reality but a 4-4-2 with a 'diamond' midfield set-up, similar to how Chelski play is the preferred method for Paul Hart.

This is a set-up that Michael Brown has told The News he likes, and thinks is 'coming on' well: 'the diamond has been coming along well and having those extra numbers in midfield has helped in the second halves of a lot of games lately.

'It's been a touch unusual for me to play on the left side of a diamond and I'm still learning that position, rather than coming on to the ball centrally.'

Brown is also confident that we will avoid the drop, but his thoughts on formations are what interested me the most...

He also feels that this is something we will 'change' at times to 'mix it up' as we will be too 'one dimensional' otherwise - although, and this is not me knocking Hart too much, I am not that sure that he will 'mix it up' too much to be honest - against 'the big boys' he might, but this will just be to go 4-5-1 I would suspect to really pack the midfield, which is fair enough.

To be fair this is working fairly well, the problem is we are so narrow!

We tend to break fairly quickly but you need some width and we are not getting enough of this, we tend to be finding again that the width is offered by one of the strikers, we then find we are short of numbers in the box as the one you want to be finishing the chances is supplying them - that said we are seeing people arrive from the midfield.

Width is certainly something we could do with, as this will help...

Although that said, to be fair to Hart, we do not exactly have an abundance of wide players available to him, do we?

Yep, Tommy Smith can do this, as can Nadir Belhadj and 'apparently so' John Utaka but Hart is happier keeping the midfield compact and using this as a further shield for the defence.

It all comes down to getting the balance right though.

For me, the quartet of Jamie O'Hara, Kevin-Prince Boateng, Hassan Yebda and Brown do this pretty well.

I think and do try to get wide, and certainly offer more support attacking wise but I would like to see Belhadj introduced into this mix a little more, especially when one of those 4 is out - as it is, and I am not trying to single Aaron Mokoena out, who gives everything - and I have really hated hearing getting booed by his own fans, when we bring him in we lose so much attacking impetus and the diamond does not seem to work - if used in this surely he needs to be at the back of this, and this is not always the case.

So, all in all I tend to agree with Brown that this is working - but we really need injuries and suspensions to be kind to us as when they are not that is when it looks much less affective!

'If/when' this happens that is when I think Hart probably needs to be thinking more along the lines of 'mixing it up'.

Some players just cannot fit into a system that you might prefer, this is when you have to rethink and change things - stubbornness will get you nowhere. So, at times you cannot keep trying to put those round pegs into square holes, trying a different formation that better suits, not accommodates, players is sometimes needed...

PLAY UP POMPEY!


Bookmark and Share


Join the Vital Pompey Debate



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer: pompeyrug Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday November 11 2009

Time: 3:00PM

Your Comments

yh the diamond formation is working great at the moment
PompeyFcMad
Sorry....but to play an effective diamond you need width. Unless of coarse you are Chelski. But come on!!!! Pompey till I die maybe, but we haven't got the quality that enables this system to work like they have. Far too narrow. I'd far rather us go 4-4-2 and go for it. FFS we need goals.
cornypomp
actually i agree with corny.
PompeyFcMad
The only problem we have with this diamond formation is when defending. We are being outplayed on the wings and have conceded too many goals especially from the left.
Pompey Malta
We don't have sufficient depth of quality to cover for the risks that come with the diamond formation. We prove it regularly.
russellm
our recent form is not that bad - won two, drawn one, lost two (in the league) and that has come since we started playing the diamond, so I say keep it up!
pros7
This formation works at it's best with pacy wing-backs which Chelski have. When we've played Belhadj and VDB in these positions the forward play has been far more productive. Our problem is both of these guys are not that hot when it actually comes to defending in their respective back positions.
cornypomp
Hi guys, I commented on the Hermninator story that in football these days you need 6 games, for consistancy, form and fitness. I can't understand why Hart swaps it about with the dreaded 4-5-1, diamond, and 4-4-2. It must be a personnel thing. Pompey need consistancy, that means in formation mainly. The players just get used to playing one way, when bang, hey presto, we are changing again. It's not right. Two banks of four WORKS in the Premier League. Corny you are spot on, Belhadj is not a left back, he works much better as a winger or LM. Vandenborre has really shined recently, (6 games again). He looked woeful first match. But now,.....WOW. I feel the trouble with Paul Hart is tactically he has no courage and he definately has no plan B. I just remember the 4-4-2 we played with a strike force of Kamara, Yak, and Lua Lua. Ok, not the best players in the world but what what they all had was pace, strength and skill. Very exciting to watch going forward.
veccccio
Lets FIFA10

Have Your Say

Click here to register an account

Recent Articles

3 games to save our season... (Tuesday February 9 2010)

A gradual handover to the fans? (Tuesday February 9 2010)

On this day in history...9th February (Tuesday February 9 2010)

Stay of execution? (Monday February 8 2010)

Pompey v Sunderland (Monday February 8 2010)

Minutes of Premier League meeting (Monday February 8 2010)

Pompey competition update #24 (Monday February 8 2010)

On this day in history...8th February (Monday February 8 2010)

Capitulation!! (Sunday February 7 2010)

If we are going lets go fighting! (Sunday February 7 2010)

On this day in history...7th February (Sunday February 7 2010)

Stats: Manyoo v Pompey 06-02-10, 3pm (Saturday February 6 2010)

Match Day Live - Manyoo v Pompey (Saturday February 6 2010)

United v Pompey (mark 4) (Saturday February 6 2010)

On this day in history...6th February (Saturday February 6 2010)

SOS Pompey - Premier league meeting (Friday February 5 2010)

Wilson staying with Pompey (Friday February 5 2010)

Premier league meeting (Friday February 5 2010)

Chainrai on 'taking over' (Friday February 5 2010)

Green and Gold (Friday February 5 2010)

On this day in history...5th February (Friday February 5 2010)

Dindane signed permanently? (Thursday February 4 2010)

James to waive his extension clause (Thursday February 4 2010)

Grant and James reflect on Fulham (Thursday February 4 2010)

Fulham 1-0 Pompey (Thursday February 4 2010)

Pompey under NEW ownership AGAIN!? (Thursday February 4 2010)

On this day in history...4th February (Thursday February 4 2010)

Match Day Live - Fulham v Pompey (Wednesday February 3 2010)

On the Verge of Greatness (Wednesday February 3 2010)

Serbian free agent 'linked' (Wednesday February 3 2010)

On this day in history...3rd February (Wednesday February 3 2010)

Fulham v Pompey (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Worth a read perhaps... (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Pompey competition update #23 (Tuesday February 2 2010)

All about the Pompey Supporters Trust (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Rocha - and others - to arrive (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Taking the fight to the premier league (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Did he, did he not? (Tuesday February 2 2010)

On this day in history...2nd February (Tuesday February 2 2010)

Mahoto heads home (Monday February 1 2010)

Ricardo Rocha .. Anybody ? (Monday February 1 2010)

What do we have to play with ? (Monday February 1 2010)

Sunderland in for James? (Monday February 1 2010)

Stoke offer for Begovic REJECTED!!! (Monday February 1 2010)

Nugent back at Burnley (Monday February 1 2010)

Fernandes coming back? (Monday February 1 2010)

Scum v Pompey - SOLD OUT! (Monday February 1 2010)

Ritchie off to Swindon? (Monday February 1 2010)

Grant reflects on Citeh loss (Monday February 1 2010)

Deadline Day Laughs (Monday February 1 2010)

Deadline Day Live (Monday February 1 2010)

ACON And The Winner Is.... (Monday February 1 2010)

On this day in history...1st February (Monday February 1 2010)

Match Day Live - Pompey v Man City (Sunday January 31 2010)

On this day in history...31st January (Sunday January 31 2010)

Princes v paupers (Saturday January 30 2010)

Promised Land? (Saturday January 30 2010)

Kaboul departure confirmed (Saturday January 30 2010)

Pompey competition update #22 (Saturday January 30 2010)

Wanted! Footballs soul back! (Saturday January 30 2010)

Where has the 'withheld' money gone? (Saturday January 30 2010)

Begovic to join Spurs/Stoke/Arsenal (Saturday January 30 2010)

A Citeh point of view (Saturday January 30 2010)

O'Hara on his return (Saturday January 30 2010)

On this day in history...30th January (Saturday January 30 2010)

Fit and proper - yea right! (Friday January 29 2010)

No wages, yet... (Friday January 29 2010)

VIDEO Preview: Man City - Portsmouth (Friday January 29 2010)

Some 'good news!' (Friday January 29 2010)

Adding insult to injury! (Friday January 29 2010)

On this day in history...29th January (Friday January 29 2010)

Official word does exist then... (Friday January 29 2010)

FFS Kaboul I get, but Begovic too? (Thursday January 28 2010)

Scummers Tickets - Details (Thursday January 28 2010)

Bills Bills Bills (Thursday January 28 2010)

O'Neil 'linked' with return, again... (Thursday January 28 2010)

On this day in history...28th January (Thursday January 28 2010)

Transfers: IN - Quincy Owusu-Abeyie (Wednesday January 27 2010)

VIDEO Highlights: Portsmouth 1-1 West Ham (Wednesday January 27 2010)

David who? (Wednesday January 27 2010)

Grant reflects on West Ham draw (Wednesday January 27 2010)

Get Adobe Flash player
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Chix 260
2. pompeyrug 211
3. PompeyFcMad 136
4. PFCblue 123
5. Gandor1 111
6. eastneydave 103
7. pentonpompey 90
8. Pompeytim 88
9. pompeyhussler 87
10. mslorna48 85

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
14. Hull City 25 5 9 11 -25 24
15. Burnley 24 6 5 13 -22 23
16. Wigan 23 6 5 12 -23 23
17. Bolton 23 5 7 11 -15 22
18. West Ham 24 4 9 11 -10 21
19. Wolves 24 5 6 13 -22 21
20. Portsmouth 24 4 3 17 -22 15

Breaking League News

City 2 Bolton 0
» Man City : 09/02/2010 22:03:00
And our defence tomorrow is....
» Spurs : 09/02/2010 19:05:00
Chelsea - No, Thank You JT
» Chelsea : 09/02/2010 17:50:00
West Ham - Zola Hits Out At Money Talk!
» West Ham : 09/02/2010 17:47:00
Ferdinand - Bowing to Pressure (Already)?
» Chelsea : 09/02/2010 17:37:00
Chelsea - It Could Have Been So Different!
» Chelsea : 09/02/2010 17:25:00
Are they Becoming Extinct?
» Chelsea : 09/02/2010 17:11:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Straight choice:- Stay up or beat scum
Suggested By: wellyit/tracyc
Stay up, lose to scum 63%
Relegation, beat scum 37%
as seen on newsnow.co.uk