Vital Football

Hart on Benfica defeat

Hart on Benfica defeat

Pompey were giving a roasting by Benfica last night, instantly after this Paul Hart spoke to The Pompey Site about his thoughts on this mauling, and it was a mauling lets be honest - we could easily have lost by more than the 4-0 final result...

Hart on the 4-0 defeat

'Considering the situation I think we did well to keep it to four.

'The lads worked hard in a very difficult situation. It was Benfica's 16th game, so I've absolutely no criticism of them.

'We got some more fitness work in. We were put under severe pressure all over the pitch which I think we'll benefit from.'

Containment always seemed to be the name of the game before hand, and clearly given these thoughts that was the case - although it was pretty evident to be honest, and thankfully, from a morale point of view it was not any worse than 4-0 as this would have had go through that breaking point, which some are reaching, others have already gone through...

Clearly Benfica are much more advanced with their pre-season training, so fitness will be much higher but the gulf in quality was clear to see... We had some moments but an air of dejection was soon cast over the players, some more so than others, but if nothing else this should act as a wake-up call, right?

Hart on 'what we can take from the game'

'They all worked tremendously hard. I'm just looking at what they can get from that game rather than the result.

'Distin, Kaboul, Belhadj, Kranjcar - I think those players did tremendously well.

'We know where we are and we know what we still have to do.'

Is it safe to assume that these four are almost certain to be in his starting 11 when we play Fulham? Mentioning some by name ahead of others would suggest so.

Sylvan Distin and Younes Kaboul must strike up an understanding, this will be essential for us that they do and there are some signs that they can/will - Distin appeared to lead the side well, which is a plus but Kaboul made stupid and needless errors at times again, errors that can and will need to be cut out.

Nadir Belhadj was the same, made needless errors that on the whole we escaped with - he is still such an exciting - sorry not 'exiting', even if unpredictable talent and one that I feel we probably need to keep around as there are not many, if any, others in the squad that can offer the blistering pace and amazing skill that he can, even if, like I say, he is totally unpredictable...

As for Niko Kranjcar, we will need him on song, we will need him to pull the strings as he is the man that Hart is clearly looking to build a team around - if he can do this for us, which he showed more than a few glimpses of last night, then it will help big time.

Hart on Finnan

Steve's nicked his hamstring so we'll have to see what happens with that. We're not sure yet how bad it is yet.'

Incredible - and this will have some almost 'gloating' at the fact that Steve Finnan, someone they 'knew would break down' did break down after only 25 minutes. Did he not warm up enough at half time, or is he just as injury prone as suspected? Either way I guess it is not worth pointing any fingers of blame as it is not going to make it better...

Finnan seemed devastated by this, and to be fair he looked ok before this setback, but you have to seriously worry that this is a sign of things to come - we cannot, without any shadow of a doubt allow any of the right back cover to leave as it would seem far to risky, I think I would give Yassin Moutaouakil another run-out against Rangers next weekend as he looked ok again in the time he was given.

Hart on judging him when others arrive

'It was always going to be a difficult tournament for us because we haven't signed many players yet.

'But we've got our targets and we're trying to close them down.

'We've got a lot of targets and we're looking at a lot of players. We're trying to whittle them down and get them in.

'Hopefully we'll have some updates when we get back from Portugal.'

First and foremost Hart needs some help, he needs a no.2 alongside him!

Ian Woan has helped him, but he lacks experience and for me is too similar to Hart in his approach - we desperately have to hope that Brian Kidd is well enough and able enough, to want to return? If it is not Kidd, then it must be someone with experience, and for me, also someone that does have something of an attacking string to their bow...

In all honesty I must admit that even I am starting to crack somewhat, things are not looking pretty - we are looking disjointed, dishevelled and without a doubt void of attacking ideas and we need some movement to happen through the Fratton gates and not out of them!

As we all know it is going to be a difficult season and Hart will find it hard going from the looks of things - but lets be fair his arms are totally tied, what can he do?

The most worrying thing is that there still - despite the obvious lack of the attacking intent in the squad to work with - very, very much a tendency to go for the defensive thoughts first, although to be fair I think we had to try and shut up shop big time last night as 4-0 could have easily become 8, 9 or 10-0 otherwise! That said despite a horrible looking deep almost 10 man back line it still could have been worse and we did start with a fairly negative outlook from the off... Like I say though, there is little offensively to work with, I just hope that we can add this attacking intent and use this.

All in all though, despite having reservations about Hart's ability to play any other way, I think that it is only fair to wait until the season begins, and then see how the first handful of games go, and see what he can do with the team he has in place - which I would really, really hope includes at least 2 or 3 new players by the time we face Fulham.

What I do know is without our support and backing this season - as tough as it can be with an almost radio silence coming from the club when all we want is some answers - we will not have much of a hope so lets do this, so lets at least start on a positive note, if we go in defeatist then we are done for...


Bookmark and Share

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Sunday August 2 2009
Time: 9:35AM


I think that you've hit most things here, Rug. I'm yet to be convinced by Kaboul and would be tempted to play Mokena there. Belhadj did not look good again, "exiting talent" might be right. And the appointment of the right assistant is perhaps the one that can save Hart's job.
02/08/2009 09:45:00
Iagree Rug, with most of what you said there, and come matchday I will be there, supporting the lads as fully as ever before, but O F*** is all I can think. Having watched that last night, we are far too deep, made little attempt at trying to put any real pressure on Benfica, and I am more concerned that our final couple of quality players are likely to want to leave than I am confident anyone will come in. Lets be fair, if you are a reasonable quality player and you have seen our results, heard of ourstyle of play, and are not going to be seduced by ludicrous wages because they can't be offered - would you come? I truly hope we can get some quality in, and as you say, support a move for a more attacking number 2 to Hart, but I am not sure any of the names we have been linked with are goingf to offer what we need! Hey - I remember Crewew and Huddersfiled etc, those were the days I learnt to lovefootball so I WILL BE HERE!
02/08/2009 10:29:00
SoundbitePaul Hart says..'We've got a lot of targets and we're looking at a lot of players. We're trying to whittle them down and get them in.

Chix says..On behalf of every Pompey fan...Well please pull your ******** finger out
02/08/2009 10:46:00
It's clear we need a couple of strikers first and foremost as we don't look like we can hit a barn door, or even anywhere in the farm at the moment. I think it would be stupid to rely on playing defensive football next season because it makes it so much harder to get back in the game if you go 1 or 2 down and with no decent strikers near on impossible. If Zaki doesn't mess about then he will be a handfull upfront coz of his size and he definately has an eye for goal. Also to have someone like Kalinic with speed and enthusiasm playing off him could make for a exiting partnership. The only other alternative is to have Kanu and Viduka up there as where they won't move much the opposition may get sucker-punched with their stealthy attacks! Could prove a problem with being offside though?! PUP
02/08/2009 11:34:00
Maybe we need another centre back and can move Kaboul to right-back where he can perform quite well and get away with a cock up or two
02/08/2009 11:57:00
Mmmmn that's good thinking Paul. But who's available on the cheap? Kaboul on the occasions he stood in for Glen last season certainly provided some forward movement in his play and caused some problems.
02/08/2009 12:30:00
Someone like Senderos would be an option, but he will not come cheap, otherwise Robert Huth could be worth a punt.
02/08/2009 19:30:00
could any english team, play against abroad at players like Aimar and Saviola and do well? even the top ones would have to fight hard because they have a different attitude to football and get confused by the passes and constant forward movement, and also portugese teams like to show they are injured often, even in they are not really badly
02/08/2009 19:39:00
Mokoena can play as centre back. Despite the evident problem up front, I think we need a creative midfielder who can bring strikers into action and manage the game from midfield. And someone who is attack-minded.
Pompey Malta
02/08/2009 22:39:00
I suppose it all boils down to it being a desimated side that even if we had bought a couple of players by now would still be struggling to gel and might even have had less motivation than the triallists that were played - one thing is for sure though... don't bother with doing this again next year unless we've got a settled squad which we're looking to make the odd key addition to. We'd have been better off playing non-league in the UK and letting Hart play about.
03/08/2009 07:51:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

On this day in history...21st February

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st February.

Stats: Fleetwood Town v Portsmouth

All the stats from Fleetwood Town (1) vs (2) Portsmouth, Highbury Stadium, 20/1/18 Att: 2,561

Fleetwood v Portsmouth - Team Sheets (20/2/18)

Fleetwood Town are at Highbury Stadium with Portsmouth the visitors today, this is a 7.45pm kick-off - the line-ups have been confirmed.

Follow Fleetwood v Pompey Live On Twitter - 20/2/18

Portsmouth travel to Fleetwood Town at Highbury Stadium today, this will be a 7.45pm kick-off.

Portsmouth Archived Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Fleetwood MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Ronan0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

10.Dorking Pompey7
Vital Football Comment