Vital Football

This is your year Martin Cranie?

This is your year Martin Cranie?

'This is Martin Cranie's year', not my vote, yours - although these findings from race's poll are thoughts that I kind of agree with...

I would agree that this year has to be the year for Cranie to come out of the shadows at Pompey or there will not be a year for him at the club, although I am not entirely sure that he has the capability of making a spot his own in the Pompey side?

The departure of Glen Johnson has left a massive spot that needs replacing - to be honest we are not going to be able to replace that void, merely fill it and whilst we have several candidates to do this Cranie is arguably the most recognisable right back that we have...problem I have is I am not certain of his ability to play a premier league season, right back or not!

That said, Stuart Pearce is no mug is he and knows a thing or two about being a full back, so if he rates Cranie enough to keep picking him for the England U21 side he must be doing something right eh? Although premier league football is a far cry from that at U21 level really isn't it.

For me Cranie has to make the step-up to the 1st team next season for Pompey, if he does not I cannot see him having a long-term future at Fratton - but is this long-term as a right back or central defender, that I guess is the real question that needs answering...

  • What the poll asked - Is it a good time for Martin Cranie to step up to the first eleven given his England under 21 status?

  • How you voted - Yes, this is his year 75%, No he will not ever be a premier league regular 13%, Bring him on through the reserves for another season 8%, Farm him out for another year 4%

    Before we move on what are your thoughts on what the last poll concluded? You know what to do, thoughts below please guys...

    PLAY UP POMPEY!

    Join the Vital Pompey Debate

    Boot the Sun out of Pompey!

  • Writer:pompeyrug
    Date:Tuesday June 23 2009
    Time: 7:55AM

    Comments

    0
    I voted that i would like to see him step up to the first team, however, we desperatley need a new centre back. One with experience!
    nodster
    23/06/2009 08:13:00
    0
    Yes, between Cranie, Wilson and Kaboul we have numbers but maybe a little short on Prem experience. I do think we need another centre back.
    bluedr
    23/06/2009 08:38:00
    0
    Think Cranie should be given a chance. He will be a different player to GJ in as much as he will be more of a full back and I believe a better defender given a run of games. Thats not a having a pop at GJ as overall he was superb for us, however at times he did leave us a bit exposed as he ventured at times to far up the pitch. All the very best to you GJ you deserve the crack at Pool. Back to Cranie, 'yes' and with Kaboul, Distin and Herman along side him. Still a very strong back 4.
    blarmy
    23/06/2009 08:49:00
    0
    I disagree - don't think Cranie is up to it. If it's all we've got then it's all we've got, but I think we need a top-class right back to fill in once the top-class right back we already have goes. That said, prove me wrong Cranie!!
    PFCGino
    23/06/2009 09:11:00
    0
    I would like him to be given a chance,bring him into the first team squad and given a run of games we might find a good RB option. Saying that, if the side don't have the points by mid season I think we will have to buy in the Jan window and this means he could find himself struggling to get into the squad.
    race
    23/06/2009 09:26:00
    0
    I think it's a straight forward case of nothing ventured nothing gained. If he doesn't get a crack at it, both he and we will never know. What's the point of bringing through a young player who shows promise and then cut him short on gaining further experience in the first team. Glen Johnson didn't actually perform very well when he first played for us, making lots of defensive errors, but we all know how he turned out. You never know, we just may have a jem in Cranie waiting to break out.
    cornypomp
    23/06/2009 09:26:00
    0
    In the couple of run out he has had he looked more than adequate to play in that role. Ok, so he may not replace Johnno and his wonder goals, who in our hearts replaced Super Matty and his wonder goals, but a few decent slide tackles and crunches of players off the ball will do me fine! Bring it on Cranie this is your moment!
    sneakay
    23/06/2009 11:38:00
    0
    I'm not convinced. GL isn't far from being truly world class & almost irreplaceable. Craine has it in him to do well but without decent players around hime will get exposed. Still a championship player in my opinion.
    storagematt
    23/06/2009 13:19:00
    Page 1/1
    1. 1

    Login to post a comment

    Best of Vital Network

    Recent Portsmouth Articles

    FA End Betting Sponsorship

    Late yesterday afternoon, the Football Association announced the result of its three month review of their relationship with gambling companies and that association now comes to an end.

    No new Pompey deal for Hunt

    Noel Hunt, signed on a one year deal after leaving Southend last summer, which came after spells at the likes of Reading, Leeds and Ipswich, isn't in Pompey's future plans.

    Done and dusted - Pompey sign Swindon's Thompson

    Out-of-contract at the County Ground, Thompson was offered a new deal at Swindon but opted to end to his Robins career after League One relegation. He signed a two year deal at Pompey.

    Davies to Tranmere as Blues close in on Thompson?

    With Burgess, Clarke and Whatmough ahead of him Davies' chances at Pompey are limited, especially if Swindon's Thompson completes move to Fratton Park - Davies could join Tranmere?

    Archived Vital Pompey Articles

    Vital Pompey articles from

    Site Journalists

    pompeyrug
    Editor email
    Profile
    eastneydave
    Editor email
    Profile
    paultsmouth
    no email
    Profile

    Current Poll (see more polls)

    Thoughts on Jackett's first signing Nathan Thompson
    Suggested By: pompeyrug
    Happy, we needed another right back32%
    Disappointed, not good enough0%
    Unsure, need to see more of him7%
    I'll trust Jackett's judgement61%
    ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
    Vital Football Comment
    Latest F1 News
    Latest Vital Boxing News
    Write for Vital Football

    Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

    Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

    Vital Members League Table

    RankNamePoints
    1.pompeyrug78
    2.eastneydave27
    3.PompeyFrippy20
    4.Copnor4313
    5.penton6
    6.mslorna486
    7.storagematt6
    8.stubbsy0073
    9.pompeyweller3
    10.robertpog3
    The Vital Football Members League