Vital Football

The Vital Pompey most stupid act was...

The Vital Pompey most stupid act was...

Selling Pedro Mendes!

I would totally agree with this, and as such of course voted that way as I would not say that appointing Tony Adams was exactly the wrong thing to do - ok, it might not have been the right thing but it was something that we had little or no option but to do given our financial standing at that time, plus who would have come in from outside to have had their hands tied as he did? Not many, if any! To be fair a large amount of Pompey fans did want this, and I would say more were for than again even if there were some 'reservations', to say the least, about this...

Selling Mendes was stupid for a variety of reasons for me:

* We sold a player that always gave everything for the club and was not lacking in quality either - quality that we would be crying out for throughout most of the season! He might not have quite been the same since he was 'assaulted' by the hooligan Ben Thatcher and 'attacked' by the thug Joey Barton but he still had more than enough about him.

* We sold him for peanuts! Did the measly £2.5m, or thereabouts, that we got for him really make that much difference? Did the savings on his wages, which although must have been pretty good would not have been astronomical really need to be made that desperately?

* We had already sold Sulley Muntari and of course Lassana Diarra was a nailed on certainty to be sold in January, so with the quality and flair that we already had ripped out of the team already 'giving away more' was strange to say the least...

Ok, the guy would have wanted to play more than he had been but surely he would have been - or at least should have been - one of the first names on the team sheet each week last season! I know 'sacrifices' had to be made, but that sacrifice is still one to this day that I think was the wrong one, well more than wrong, hence 'the most stupid act of the season!'

Over the years we had sold so many players that gave their all for the club, we sold out this passion and commitment, and to be fair quality, for greater quality admittedly but when this greater quality looked to be being offloaded one at a time surely we needed to not only retain some of this, but that undoubted commitment to the club - something that Pedro had plenty of, but there you go.

These are the thoughts that were shared about him in the forum poll voting...

pompeyrug: 'I guess I will kick off the comments then...

I went for 'selling Mendes' - with it obviously clear that our midfield was lacking, the very heartbeat being ripped out the decision to allow mendes, who would clearly have a part to play and had so much to offer was a very bad thing! I know we had to 'balance the books' but did the savings on his wages and the measly £3m, if that, we got for him really make that much difference?

We must have known that it was almost 'nailed on' that Diarra would leave in the January window so we would be even shorter than we already were?'

powered_by_pies: 'I agree. Selling Mendes was one of the stupidest things ever done.

Oh how we need him right now. Thing is, even if we offered to throw untold amounts of cash at him, I doubt he'd come back. He's just won the SPL title with Rangers, and he's already seen as a hero oop narth. :-('

UKTony: 'Mendes gets my vote.'

pompeycarpet: 'It wasn't just Mendes though. It was the fact that we sold three midfielders, and didn't replace any of them!

(Basinas doesn't count, as he didn't play, and Mullins doesn't count, because he's worse than we had already!)'

Lemmi: 'Yes it's Mendes for me.'

Squee: 'Mendes gets my vote too. Although Adams' reign was woeful it couldn't really have been predicted how bad it would have been and, as they say, hindsight is a wonderful thing.

The problems of selling Mendes on the other hand should have been thought out much better. I'm glad the fella's enjoying himself up there in Glasgow - I should think the move from the sunny south coast was a bit of a culture shock!'

A decent number of votes in this one, so to see how this voting went click here.

Keep a look out for the other categories that will be appearing in the forum over the coming weeks...

PLAY UP POMPEY!

Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Win FREE pizza with Vital Football!
Select your team and get 50% off if they score twice.
www.papajohns.co.uk/football



For the very latest Premier League odds

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:pompeyrug
Date:Saturday June 6 2009
Time: 12:49PM

Comments

0
we would have done much much better if we had still had mendes.
pompeycarpet
06/06/2009 15:39:00
0
Look it's so easy with hindsight. He wanted to leave because he wasn't playing nearly enough, so we had little say. And when you get offered fairly good money for someone who's not in your first team, then you have to take it. Especially with the financial situation we were in. Personally I don't think we would have been that much better over this season with him.
jonathanl50
06/06/2009 15:56:00
0
but we'd already sold muntari, and at the time, we had been playing a 3 man midfield, and he HAD been in the team. AND it wasn't even good money.
pompeycarpet
06/06/2009 16:12:00
0
It was Mendez or Davies to go, as I remember, with Redknapp suggesting that Davies was refusing to go. I always felt that the sale of Muntari was the end of the chance for a second season in Europe and whether we had Mendez or Davies was a bit "six of one, half a dozen..."
Pompeyscum
06/06/2009 18:16:00
0
A player had to be sold and Mendes was the only one prepared to move. Others such as Nugent, Traore were happy to atay on their huge salaries not worried about playing or not.
eastneydave
06/06/2009 18:44:00
0
I blame Davis digging his heels in & not going. HR was told to sell another player & Mendes, sadly went. We certainly never replaced him & the fact he could score goals made him priceless.
storagematt
06/06/2009 19:07:00
0
Pompeyscum you got it spot on.
pompeyyong
06/06/2009 19:23:00
0
The fact that Davis was not a regular when we had players shows that he isn't good enough, even if he pleyed well last season. Mendes is much better, at least he can hit the goal. I would give Basinas, Mullins, Pele and Hughes, our midfiled men last season for Pedro.
Pompey Malta
06/06/2009 22:55:00
0
I don't know whether Diop was injured at the time of the Mendez sale but his loss was a major blow. His form dips but last season would have made him a very important player for the club. Bad year for all concerned.
Pompeyscum
07/06/2009 01:07:00
0
I got the impression at the time that Mendes jumped at the chance to go to Rangers, its difficult, possilby foolhardy to try to stop them going if that's what they want. But he has been a great loss to us, all of the midfielders have. Lets hope soon we start building our midfield back up again.
tracyc
07/06/2009 08:26:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

The Fear faces Ben Nevis!

Vitalfootball.co.uk co-owner Jonathan Fear is pushing himself to the limit in order to raise funds for Cystic Fibrosis.

On this day in history...3rd May

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 3rd May.

Who Will Portsmouth Face In 2016/17 (3/5/16)

With less than a handful of games remaining in the 2015/16 campaign, some promotions and relegations in the football pyramid are already known.

April MotM Nomination - Cook (Portsmouth)

The April nominations for the Sky Bet League 2 Manager of the Month Award are in.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

pompeyrug
Editor email
Profile
eastneydave
Editor email
Profile
paultsmouth
no email
Profile
Chix
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Hartlepool MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Murphy51%
Stevens0%
Burgess7%
Barton0%
Freeman0%
Doyle0%
Hollands3%
Naismith19%
Roberts11%
Evans0%
Smith3%
Sub - McGurk0%
Sub - Chaplin3%
Sub - Whatmough3%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Northampton 45 28 12 5 96 35
2 Accrington 45 24 12 9 84 26
3 Oxford 45 23 14 8 83 40
4 Bristol Rovers 45 25 7 13 82 30
5 Portsmouth 45 21 15 9 78 32
6 Plymouth 45 23 9 13 78 21
7 Wimbledon 45 20 12 13 72 13
8 Cambridge 45 18 13 14 67 11
9 Leyton Orient 45 18 12 15 66 -2
10 Wycombe 45 17 13 15 64 4
11 Exeter 45 17 13 15 64 1
12 Carlisle 45 16 16 13 64 0
13 Mansfield 45 17 12 16 63 8
14 Luton 45 18 9 18 63 -1
15 Barnet 45 16 11 18 59 -4
16 Hartlepool 45 15 6 24 51 -18
17 Notts County 45 14 9 22 51 -24
18 Yeovil 45 11 15 19 48 -15
19 Stevenage 45 11 14 20 47 -15
20 Crawley 45 13 8 24 47 -30
21 Morecambe 45 12 9 24 45 -22
22 Newport 45 10 13 22 43 -20
R Dag & Red 45 8 10 27 34 -34
R York 45 7 12 26 33 -36
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

May 7 2016 3:00PM : Northampton Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.storagematt5
2.Emsworthianblue3
3.Copnor433
4.mslorna482
5.FrattonBlue2
6.eastneydave2