UK time is: 12:12:03
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Premier League All Time Starting XI

We all know that many of us (namely Dave, Chix, Tim, and Tony) know all about Pompey past and present, and that we have no problem in naming our best team ever.

What happens though if you had to name the best Premier League team ever covering all the players from all the Premier League Teams? Would you be able to do it? Who would be in your dream team if you had the chance to pick one?

Well now is your chance, as Vital Pompey are going to construct a 'Premier League All Time Starting XI'.

Here is how it works, rather than everyone just spilling out in the forum in one go causing chaos, each position (standard 4-4-2) will be placed in turn, in the site poll with a list of choices for that position for you to vote on. There will be three or four days for each vote before the position is changed to the next, and the announcement of who won is made.

I (this being sneakay) am happy to take some suggestions for each position - do this below - as I will without doubt miss at least one person here and there. There will always be the option of voting for 'other' for this reason. If you think that someone has been missed then please let me know who that other person is.

At the end of the voting the full line up will be announced, and then the chaotic debating on our choices can be started.

So to kick it all off we are going to start with the Keepers. Please take a look at the site poll and make your vote.

Join the Vital Pompey Debate




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: sneakay Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday July 16 2008

Time: 8:43AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Know all about Pompey past and present?? I can't remember what I was doing last week, half the time! Seriously though, this is a good debating ground Sneakay. I've done mine.No brainer from the list given (shame Alan Knight wasn't around in PL days)
UKTony
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 08:50:00

Nothing like nabbing an idea off another site ;)
marron
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 09:04:00

.and calamity James? you have to be kidding me - the man is an accident (or 2,3,4,5 etc.) waiting to happen.
marron
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 09:05:00

How is Peter Schmeichel not winning this poll?!
TheSlaven
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 09:12:00

He is now!
marron
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 09:39:00

Should be interesting!
storagematt
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 10:22:00

Sneakay - what would you do if 'Other' won the poll?
eastneydave
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 10:40:00

Dave - Allow Alan Knight and John Milkins in for a "play off" :)
UKTony
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 10:43:00

David James in this list is a joke right?! No Shay Given, Neville Southall but James makes it.
North Upper
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:04:00

wat about shaka hislop?
Sulley Fan
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:08:00

Cudicini?
Adilson
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:11:00

Not sure why everyone is having a go at Jamo? His great saves far outweigh his clangers. No one has a go at Ronald if he misses a chance because he scores more than he misses. Neville Southall brilliant as he was, probably at his best prior to the prem. Given, maybe when he is fit but what have Newcastle ever achieved with him in goal? Cudicini, not quite.
storagematt
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:23:00

who is nabbing what from other sites marron? these kinds of things are done all the time arent they...
james has played in every premier league season, hence - i assume? - for his inclusion in the poll?
cudicini is a fantastic keeper, but hasnt played enough football to be considered a 'great' has he, shay given i will give North Upper that one but southall as great a keeper as he was, his best days were gone really during his premier league years - which again were quite limited. one of britains greatest ever tho! at the end of the day these would all fall into 'other' anyway...
as it stands jamo is 2nd in the poll, as great as i think he is now i dont agree that over the course of the premier league he is the 2nd greatest ever tbh...
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:25:00

you must have been tying as i was mate, similar thoughts there - great minds they say... maybe not :-)
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 11:26:00

Well I am glad to see that everyone has already started debating without me. I wanted to limit the choices, and as mentiond I will probably not think of someone. I don't see why everyone is having ago about Jamo in the Poll. It's funny how everyone remebers you for your mistakes and not the great saves you constantly have made over the last 10 years.
sneakay
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 13:03:00

unfair to right of David James, he made mistakes when he was younger but learned from them. he's been at the highest level for so long he must be doing something right. All goal keepers make mistakes, unfortunately for them a mistake usually results in a goal, elsewhere on the pitch you've a very good chance of getting away with it. I saw him play at Fratton for Watford and he was brilliant thought then he'd go all the way. Harry had the right idea at least by signing him he's ended his habit of playing blinders against us. Maybe there are a few names missing from the list. but you could raise doubts about everyone, Seaman was brilliant but perhaps played a little too long. Schmeichel superb at united, ordinary afterwards. Friedel certainly a good keeper but probably plenty better. Van de Sar better before united. Personally I'm going for Jamo (never thought i'd ever say that) He's got better as he's got older, certainly better now than 5 years ago.
Steve C
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 13:50:00

i want chalkias.
jbaker
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 14:36:00

Yeah I can't understand why David 'Most clean sheets in the history of the premier league' James is in that list either. Bizarre.
stooH
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 14:44:00

James 3rd, Cech 2nd, Schmeichel 1st. Chalkias only misses out through shear bad luck
Pompeyscum
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 15:41:00

Got to be Schmiechel for me, raised the bar of goalkeeping in this country.
pompey4me
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 21:24:00

I agree P4me.. although I disliked his arrogance I thought he was a cracking keeper... Jamo is great for Pompey and is probably one of (if not) the best in the prem at the mo (behind Cech) but overall it has to be Schmiechel.. and to think he's secured a role in Corrie too
Chix
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 21:33:00

Corrie??? Is he in that now? Pulling my leg! Soap free house this one! (and i mean the tv thing, not the thing in the bathroom.) Yep, Jamo holds the clean sheet record, but, I dunno, it doesn't seem right voting for someone still playing? All time great implies a player that has finished doesnt it?
pompey4me
Report Abuse
16/07/2008 23:28:00

Well next up will be Right Back so if anyone has any ideas then please let me know
sneakay
Report Abuse
17/07/2008 10:08:00

i cannot stand the fella but gary neville would need to be one of the right back names wouldnt he...
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
18/07/2008 11:47:00

erm, lee dixon another? running out of names already!
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
18/07/2008 11:48:00

lauren perhaps... other right backs guys?
pompeyrug
Report Abuse
18/07/2008 11:49:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Stats: Pompey v Southend (Sunday January 25 2015)

On this day in history...25th January (Sunday January 25 2015)

On this day in history...24th January (Saturday January 24 2015)

The Tinkerman (Friday January 23 2015)

On this day in history...23rd January (Friday January 23 2015)

Pompey MOTM - Burton (h) (Thursday January 22 2015)

On this day in history...22nd January (Thursday January 22 2015)

More changes at Fratton (Wednesday January 21 2015)

On this day in history...21st January (Wednesday January 21 2015)

Archived Portsmouth Articles

List All Vital Pompey Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. gentleman jim 85
2. pompeyrug 81
3. Pompeytim 45
4. cornypomp 43
5. storagematt 29
6. eastneydave 29
7. Emsworthianblue 25
8. Copnor43 22
9. mslorna48 17
10. pompeyweller 13

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
15. Accrington 25 10 3 12 -7 33
16. Oxford 27 7 9 11 -6 30
17. Cheltenham 27 7 9 11 -13 30
18. Portsmouth 26 7 8 11 -5 29
19. York 27 5 13 9 -5 28
20. Mansfield 26 7 7 12 -12 28
21. Carlisle 27 8 3 16 -16 27

Breaking League News

Oxford team v Exeter
Oxford : 25/01/2015 10:44:00
Portsmouth : 25/01/2015 08:55:00
On this day in history...25th January
Portsmouth : 25/01/2015 07:00:00
The Opposition View - Mansfield Town
Wycombe : 25/01/2015 01:44:00
Wycombe escape Mansfield scrap with valuable point
Wycombe : 24/01/2015 21:18:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Southend
Suggested By:  pompeyrug
Jones 0%
Webster 0%
Devera 0%
Robinson 0%
Shorey 0%
Wallace 0%
Dunne 0%
Atangana (61) 0%
Barcham (74) 100%
Tubbs 0%
Westcarr (61) 0%
Sub - Hollands (61) 0%
Sub - McCallum (61) 0%
Sub - Taylor (74) 0%