Vital Football

Whittingham - no way back for Nugent

Whittingham - no way back for Nugent

The Dave Nugent highly probable loan move to Ipswich is not really something that I wanted to cover again - in article format anyway - until it happened, but after reading comments from the legendary 'corporal punishment' Guy Whittingham in The News I could not help myself...

As much as I have hoped that Nugent would cut it with Pompey, and be given the extended run that I personally feel he needed to be fully judged - which in my thinking no matter what anyone tells me he has not been given - the fact that he is being 'loaned out' does almost certainly effectively signal the end to his Pompey career.

As Whittingham has said, by allowing him to go out on loan and with no recall option - which we have allowed, and by doing so have got more money as a result, something again which personally I feel outlines we are short, but that is for another day - when you take into account that we will be left thread bare, particularly where the cup is concerned if Kanu and/or Milan Baros are injured this effectively confirms that he has no future with Pompey if we are willing to take this risk: 'it may cause problems for Pompey in the cups if Kanu or Milan Baros are injured.

'But I'm sure it's something the manager will have weighed up.

'And if that's the case you would have to say it's the beginning of the end for the lad.

'I remember being loaned out by Villa to Wolves. At Sheffield Wednesday I was loaned out to Wolves and Watford and at Pompey I was loaned out to Peterborough and Oxford.

'Each time it signalled the end of me at that particular club.

'Unless you are a very young player looking for experience, if you are loaned out usually the writing is on the wall in terms of your time at that club.

'If a manager is willing to let you go it's not good.

'In this case, Harry is prepared to let Nugent go for the rest of the season with no option to bring him back.

'It doesn't take a genius to see the situation.

'It's pretty clear the lad is not part of his plans and he is quite prepared to do without him.

'I can't see anyway back from this. I may be wrong, but I don't think I am'.

I think Whittingham makes a lot of sense, and find it hard to see him being wrong...

I just pray that this move is not one that is basically 'admitting defeat' in the bid to win the FA cup - with us prepared to 'focus' purely on the league - in many ways 'accepting' that we will be beaten by United?

Something which this 'could' now give us the chance to see is just how effective John Utaka could be through the middle, there have been many calls for him to be given a start up front as opposed to on the wing, he has often said himself he wanted this but Harry Redknapp has always said he was signed as a winger, but his tune has now changed to justify Nugent going...


Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Date:Thursday February 28 2008
Time: 9:19AM


Rug, your last paragraph makes a telling point.
28/02/2008 10:31:00
Defoe's siging nailed Nugents coffin shut i think. Not that i think Harry actually wants him to go, but he has probably admitted he is down the pecking order, so if he wants to go he wont be stopped. I think Nugent was here for the future, but that was when Harry thought getting Defoe was always going to fall through. Shame, but its life. I hope Nugent comes back and plays for us, but if he doesnt, i hope he does well elsewhere.
28/02/2008 10:44:00
When you let it go and it doesn't come back it wasn't mean't to be yours.
28/02/2008 11:31:00
HR gave an interview yesterday and said he had good strikers in Defoe, Baros, Kanu and Utaka and he had bought Utaka as a striker. An interesting comment as its the first time I can recall HR saying tat Utaka was bought as a striker and he certainly hasn't used him as one.
28/02/2008 11:42:00
in all fairness - and to defend 'arry in a way, altho at the same time he has rarely mentioned utaka in this way - when he first signed him he said he could play as a striker or a winger, has he ever really said he signed utaka as an out and out striker tho... with nuge now gone, or as good as we have no option but to use him in this way, but this will only be the case if we have to...
28/02/2008 11:54:00
I wish Nugent well, I am just grateful that he wasn't playing against us in a Preston shirt in the 5th Round. To me he is a very good Championship class player (sorry 2nd division) but he doesn't cut the mustard in the Prem. Simple as that...
28/02/2008 12:10:00
either way guys, good luck to him and let's hope he helps the Tractors get promotion...
28/02/2008 12:11:00
Don't totally agree with Guy on this one. Nugent is young and going out on loan will help play football. When Guy was loaned out by his clubs he was an experienced player surplus to requirements. Nugent could benefit and come back a better player ala Gary O'Neil.
28/02/2008 12:15:00
seems like the ball is in Nugent's and Ipswich's court according to the press - they might exercise an option and we may not have a choice of getting him back if he plays well there.
28/02/2008 12:28:00
You just hope whichever way it goes the club benefits & the player can get his career back on tracks. We are no worse without him & no doubt he will get his act together somewhere else. The only sore spot is the transfer fee paid.
28/02/2008 12:38:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Pompey MotM at Oldham

Jack Whatmough's performance was seen as the best one from a Pompey player against Oldham in last Saturday's victory at Boundary Park.

On this day in history...22nd March

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 22nd March.

On this day in history...21st March

A look back at this day in history, and what was happening with Pompey courtesy of our sister site PompeyRama, 21st March.

Beneficial for all concerned

Four defeats in five came to an end at the weekend as Pompey won at Oldham. Victory was great, but the decision to drop Christian Burgess was a main talking point ahead of this game.

Portsmouth Archived Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Pompey v Oxford
Suggested By: pompeyrug
Pompey win100%
Oxford win0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

10.Dorking Pompey3
The Vital Football Members League