Vital Football

Surely we won't loan out Nugent?

Surely we won't loan out Nugent?

I tried to fight this, as it was not something I wanted to cover as I am fed up with 'rumour' and 'speculation' surrounding Dave Nugent but the idea that he could leave us on loan just will not go away will it...

According to the Ipswich Evening Star it is being 'said' that Ipswich boss Jim Magilton has made a loan approach for Nugent for the rest of the season, and 'apparently' we are not 'entirely opposed to the idea': 'Nugent is a possibility. We have asked about taking him on loan and Portsmouth have not ruled it out.

'We are well aware if he did come he is not at 100% but he is making massive strides to get fit so we will wait and see what happens.

'He loves Portman Road and he loves scoring goals here so it would be good to have him in a Blues shirt'.

I have made my thoughts on Nugent more than clear, so I am not going to go over these again.

However in light of Harry Redknapp only a day or so ago claiming he was still 'light' when it came to strikers how could he then justify letting him going out on loan?

The only possible benefits that I could see to this could be him rediscovering his goalscoring form, but even then how would this benefit him as this would be at a level that he was trying to get away from it will not be anything new to him, so will not prove anything new will it.

So the only reason I can see the sense in loaning him out is if it has been decided once and for all that he is not wanted here, so by loaning him out if he can start scoring again at least it will get him in the public eye and could see his value held, at the very least not drop too much? There is also the chance that if he does well for Ipswich they could be interested in signing him if they get promoted?

To be honest I do not want him to go - surprise, surprise - and think that if we do then we are virtually kissing our FA cup chances goodbye as injuries to Kanu, Milan Baros or John Utaka - even though he is not being viewed as a striker - would leave us with no one... unless we had a 24 hour recall clause inserted? And I am finding it hard to belief that will can see through the rest of the cup campaign with just 2 strikers...

Redknapp says he wants to keep him, but then he does not mention him when he talks about the strikers we have, if we genuinely are contemplating letting him go on loan then to me this would speak volumes about where his future does lie...


Join the Vital Pompey Debate

Date:Wednesday February 20 2008
Time: 3:27PM


Well said Rug, Perhaps we need his wages paid!!!. If he is loaned out, lets enjoy "HR" talk his way out of that one.
20/02/2008 15:51:00
this would be totally against alot of things, especially our fa cup chances. why sell benji for 3.5m, buy nugent for 6m, and not play him?
20/02/2008 16:05:00
I hope he stays but think HR doesn't like the guy. Will have to wait and see how this one pans out.
20/02/2008 16:43:00
Actions speak louder than words and the bottom line, for whatever reason iss that Harry really given Nuge a chance .. If he is viewed as a long term fixture I'd say he should say and fight for his place... If he isn't and Harry is not gonna play him better that we get his wages paid and put him in the shop window.... Not that I wanna see him go ... but I think reality is begining to bite for young Mr Nuge...
20/02/2008 16:47:00
I don't think it makes any sense to loan him out at this stage with the cup campaign as it is and Defoe cup tied - and if that wasn't the case, the only reason I could see to loan him out would be for him to get Premier League experience, which he won't get at Ipswich. But there's been no swift denial from Arry about this, so it might happen unfortunately.
20/02/2008 17:22:00
If HR doesn't like the guy, why did he sign him?
20/02/2008 18:05:00
I'd loan him out, his confidence is low, he is not fit, he is 4th choice. Only thing I would insist on is a 24hr recall period. Playing week in, week out is better for him than being an unused sub each week
20/02/2008 19:39:00
Its not about liking or not liking its about ability. It was gamble, this one hasn't worked. Spurs paid £16m on Darren Bent, so far that hasn't worked. I agree with paultsmouth comments too. Sorry 007 you seem to have a problem with the manager?
20/02/2008 20:01:00
I think we might. And don't call me Shirley. I think this might be HR thinking he has a last chance before the summer to see whether Nugent is worth keeping or whether he's going to be sold off in the summer. Either that or because he needs to score a few goals or he won't raise enough money to be worth selling. For whatever reason, he doesn't seem to figure in HR's plans as anything more than a last option. I agree with you, Rug, I don't think it's wise and there is every chance we'll come to regret it. But I won't be surprised.
20/02/2008 20:21:00
I think Nugent could shine given the chance. I have predicted he will score against Sunderland and against Man U so I have my c..k on the block. As far as I can recall HR never actually said he wanted Nugent, he obviously isn't a great fan of his and does whatever he can to make him appear useless. Nugent almost overnight appeared at Pompey after some of the quickest and smoothest negotiations that Storrie has ever been involved in. I have made mention before of Sasha wanting to appear politically correct for varying reasons. A lot has been made of HR buying African players and ignoring English players. I suspect, no proof just suspect, that Sasha may have bought Nugent not HR. HR could now be trying to "get back" at Sasha by making things appear that Nugent isn't up to it and Sasha should not have bought him so don't do it again. Politics comes into football as well. We will see but my guess is that Nugent will stay and be given more of a chance (he who pays the wages has the biggest say) and Baros will be the one moved to the bench except for cup ties.
21/02/2008 04:08:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Portsmouth Articles

Pompey couldn't... could we? Part 2

Well, it's still on after the Cambridge win. Pompey CAN win league two ahead of Doncaster & Plymouth... will these chances die at Mansfield or can the battle go on?

Championship Free Agents 2017

As the summer nears and contracts come to an end, should the club have an interest in any of the following free transfers from Championship oppositions?

51 Clubs Receive EFL Family Excellence Award - 2016/17

The Football League have recognised a record 51 clubs in the 2016/17 Family Excellence Awards.

Pompey Predictions League - update no.44

The Pompey Predictions League is part of this site now isn't it - would it be the same without it? This continued with a win from the visit of Cambridge - a trip to Mansfield is next.

Archived Vital Pompey Articles

Vital Pompey articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Editor email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Mansfield v Pompey?
Suggested By:
Pompey win20%
Mansfield win60%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
P Doncaster 44 25 10 9 85 33
P Plymouth 44 25 8 11 83 24
P Portsmouth 44 24 9 11 81 33
4 Luton 44 18 17 9 71 22
5 Exeter 44 20 8 16 68 18
6 Blackpool 44 17 16 11 67 22
7 Stevenage 44 20 6 18 66 7
8 Mansfield 44 17 14 13 65 5
9 Wycombe 44 18 11 15 65 4
10 Carlisle 44 16 17 11 65 -1
11 Cambridge 44 18 9 17 63 7
12 Colchester 44 17 12 15 63 6
13 Accrington 44 16 14 14 62 3
14 Grimsby 44 17 10 17 61 -2
15 Barnet 44 13 15 16 54 -6
16 Notts County 44 15 8 21 53 -22
17 Crewe 44 13 13 18 52 -11
18 Morecambe 44 14 9 21 51 -18
19 Crawley 44 13 11 20 50 -16
20 Yeovil 44 11 16 17 49 -13
21 Cheltenham 44 11 14 19 47 -16
22 Newport 44 11 12 21 45 -22
23 Hartlepool 44 10 13 21 43 -21
R Leyton Orient 44 10 6 28 36 -36
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Portsmouth Results (view all)

Portsmouth Fixtures (view all)

Apr 29 2017 3:00PM : Mansfield Town (a)
Sky Bet League Two
May 6 2017 5:30PM : Cheltenham Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

Vital Football Comment